Zama Shu, Fujioka Tomoyuki, Yamaga Emi, Kubota Kazunori, Mori Mio, Katsuta Leona, Yashima Yuka, Sato Arisa, Kawauchi Miho, Higuchi Subaru, Kawanishi Masaaki, Ishiba Toshiyuki, Oda Goshi, Nakagawa Tsuyoshi, Tateishi Ukihide
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Tokyo Medical and Dental University Hospital, 1-5-45, Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-8501, Japan.
Department of Radiology, Dokkyo Medical University Saitama Medical Center, 2-1-50 Minami-koshigaya, Koshigaya 343-8555, Japan.
Medicina (Kaunas). 2023 Dec 21;60(1):14. doi: 10.3390/medicina60010014.
This study compares the clinical properties of original breast ultrasound images and those synthesized by a generative adversarial network (GAN) to assess the clinical usefulness of GAN-synthesized images.
We retrospectively collected approximately 200 breast ultrasound images for each of five representative histological tissue types (cyst, fibroadenoma, scirrhous, solid, and tubule-forming invasive ductal carcinomas) as training images. A deep convolutional GAN (DCGAN) image-generation model synthesized images of the five histological types. Two diagnostic radiologists (reader 1 with 13 years of experience and reader 2 with 7 years of experience) were given a reading test consisting of 50 synthesized and 50 original images (≥1-month interval between sets) to assign the perceived histological tissue type. The percentages of correct diagnoses were calculated, and the reader agreement was assessed using the kappa coefficient.
The synthetic and original images were indistinguishable. The correct diagnostic rates from the synthetic images for readers 1 and 2 were 86.0% and 78.0% and from the original images were 88.0% and 78.0%, respectively. The kappa values were 0.625 and 0.650 for the synthetic and original images, respectively. The diagnoses made from the DCGAN synthetic images and original images were similar.
The DCGAN-synthesized images closely resemble the original ultrasound images in clinical characteristics, suggesting their potential utility in clinical education and training, particularly for enhancing diagnostic skills in breast ultrasound imaging.
本研究比较了原始乳腺超声图像与通过生成对抗网络(GAN)合成的图像的临床特性,以评估GAN合成图像的临床实用性。
我们回顾性收集了五种代表性组织学类型(囊肿、纤维腺瘤、硬癌、实性和小管形成性浸润性导管癌)中每种类型约200幅乳腺超声图像作为训练图像。一个深度卷积GAN(DCGAN)图像生成模型合成了这五种组织学类型的图像。两名诊断放射科医生(读者1有13年经验,读者2有7年经验)接受了一项阅读测试,测试包括50幅合成图像和50幅原始图像(两组之间间隔≥1个月),以确定所感知的组织学类型。计算正确诊断的百分比,并使用kappa系数评估读者间的一致性。
合成图像和原始图像难以区分。读者1和读者2对合成图像的正确诊断率分别为86.0%和78.0%,对原始图像的正确诊断率分别为88.0%和78.0%。合成图像和原始图像的kappa值分别为0.625和0.650。由DCGAN合成图像和原始图像做出的诊断相似。
DCGAN合成图像在临床特征上与原始超声图像非常相似,表明它们在临床教育和培训中具有潜在用途,特别是在提高乳腺超声成像诊断技能方面。