“如果你需要精神科医生,那就糟糕了”:加纳产科医护人员中与寻求心理健康护理相关的污名化现象
"If You Need a Psychiatrist, It's BAD": Stigma Associated with Seeking Mental Health Care Among Obstetric Providers in Ghana.
作者信息
Lawrence Emma R, Parekh Bela J, Owusu-Antwi Ruth, Newman Noah, Russell Colin B, Beyuo Titus K, Yeboah Michael, Oppong Samuel A, Moyer Cheryl A
机构信息
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
出版信息
Int J Womens Health. 2024 Jan 24;16:131-141. doi: 10.2147/IJWH.S440224. eCollection 2024.
PURPOSE
Globally, the COVID-19 pandemic has brought attention to the impact of negative patient outcomes on healthcare providers. In Ghana, obstetric providers regularly face maternal and neonatal mortality, yet limited research has focused on provision of mental health support for these providers. This study sought to understand how obstetric providers viewed seeking mental health support after poor clinical outcomes, with a focus on the role of mental health stigma.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
Participants were 52 obstetric providers (20 obstetrician/gynecologists and 32 midwives) at two tertiary care hospitals in Ghana. Five focus groups, led by a trained facilitator and lasting approximately two hours, were conducted to explore provider experiences and perceptions of support following poor maternal and neonatal outcomes. Discussions were audiotaped and transcribed verbatim, then analyzed qualitatively using grounded theory methodology.
RESULTS
Most participants (84.3%, N=43) were finished with training, and 46.2% (N=24) had been in practice more than 10 years. Emerging themes included pervasive stigma associated with seeking mental health care after experiencing poor clinical outcomes, which was derived from two overlapping dimensions. First, societal-level stigma resulted from a cultural norm to keep emotions hidden, and the perception that psychiatry is equated with severe mental illness. Second, provider-level stigma resulted from the belief that healthcare workers should not have mental health problems, a perception that mental health care is acceptable for patients but not for providers, and a fear about lack of confidentiality. Despite many providers acknowledging negative mental health impacts following poor clinical outcomes, these additive layers of stigma limited their willingness to engage in formal mental health care.
CONCLUSION
This study demonstrates that stigma creates significant barriers to acceptance of mental health support among obstetric providers. Interventions to support providers will need to respect provider concerns without reinforcing the stigma associated with seeking mental health care.
目的
在全球范围内,新冠疫情使人们关注到患者不良结局对医疗服务提供者的影响。在加纳,产科医疗服务提供者经常面临孕产妇和新生儿死亡的情况,但针对这些提供者的心理健康支持的研究却很有限。本研究旨在了解产科医疗服务提供者在临床结局不佳后对寻求心理健康支持的看法,重点关注心理健康污名的作用。
患者与方法
研究对象为加纳两家三级护理医院的52名产科医疗服务提供者(20名妇产科医生和32名助产士)。由一名经过培训的主持人主持,进行了五个焦点小组讨论,每组持续约两小时,以探讨医疗服务提供者在孕产妇和新生儿结局不佳后的经历和对支持的看法。讨论进行了录音并逐字转录,然后使用扎根理论方法进行定性分析。
结果
大多数参与者(84.3%,N = 43)已完成培训,46.2%(N = 24)从业超过10年。新出现的主题包括临床结局不佳后寻求心理健康护理时普遍存在的污名,这源于两个重叠的维度。首先,社会层面的污名源于隐藏情绪的文化规范,以及认为精神病学等同于严重精神疾病的观念。其次,提供者层面的污名源于认为医护人员不应有心理健康问题的信念、认为心理健康护理对患者可接受但对提供者不可接受的看法,以及对缺乏保密性的担忧。尽管许多提供者承认临床结局不佳后会对心理健康产生负面影响,但这些叠加的污名层限制了他们接受正规心理健康护理的意愿。
结论
本研究表明,污名对产科医疗服务提供者接受心理健康支持造成了重大障碍。支持医疗服务提供者的干预措施需要尊重他们的担忧,而不强化与寻求心理健康护理相关的污名。