Rani Madhu, Kapoor Sonia
University Institute of Engineering and Technology, Maharshi Dayanand University, Haryana, India.
Recent Adv Food Nutr Agric. 2024;15(3):204-214. doi: 10.2174/012772574X282571231227054442.
The present study investigates the effect of conventional and organic farming systems on the nutritional profile of crops. Different crops, namely -millet, sorghum, sesame, mustard, fenugreek, berseem, pea, potato, and onion were cultivated through conventional agriculture in which chemical fertilizers like urea, DAP (Diammonium Phosphate) and pesticides were used and organic farming in which organic fertilizers like seaweed and vermicompost were used.
The experimental study was done on a field in north India from 2019 to 2021 in six different seasons, and the nutrient profile of the crops with respect to macroelements (S, K, Na, P, Ca, Mg) and microelements (B, Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, Al) was compared.
Macro and microelements were analyzed by Element analyzer and ICP-OES in both types of farming systems. The content of macro, as well as microelements, was found to be significantly higher in all the organically produced crops as compared to the conventionally grown crops.
Significant differences were observed in the macroelement content of organic onion (P- 900 mg/kg, K-2000mg/kg) and organic pea (K 2250 mg/kg) as compared to the content of conventionally grown onion (P-756 mg/kg, K- 1550 mg/kg) and pea (K-2000 mg/kg). Similarly, microelement content in the organic sesame (Fe - 3.12 mg/kg), organic millet (Fe- 2.19 mg/kg), and organic potato (Zn-200 mg/kg) was higher as compared to conventionally grown sesame (Fe 2.05 mg/kg), millet (Fe- 1.56 mg/kg) and potato (Zn 167 mg/kg).
This investigation concludes that crops with optimum nutritional content can be produced through organic farming with minimum input and maximum production.
本研究调查了传统耕作系统和有机耕作系统对作物营养成分的影响。通过传统农业种植了不同的作物,即小米、高粱、芝麻、芥菜、葫芦巴、埃及三叶草、豌豆、土豆和洋葱,在传统农业中使用了尿素、磷酸二铵等化肥和农药;还通过有机耕作种植了这些作物,在有机耕作中使用了海藻和蚯蚓堆肥等有机肥料。
2019年至2021年在印度北部的一块田地上进行了六个不同季节的实验研究,比较了作物中大量元素(硫、钾、钠、磷、钙、镁)和微量元素(硼、铜、铁、锰、锌、铝)的营养成分。
在两种耕作系统中,通过元素分析仪和电感耦合等离子体发射光谱仪对大量元素和微量元素进行分析。结果发现,与传统种植的作物相比,所有有机生产的作物中大量元素和微量元素的含量都显著更高。
与传统种植的洋葱(磷-756毫克/千克,钾-1550毫克/千克)和豌豆(钾-2000毫克/千克)相比,有机洋葱(磷-900毫克/千克,钾-2000毫克/千克)和有机豌豆(钾-2250毫克/千克)的大量元素含量存在显著差异。同样,与传统种植的芝麻(铁-2.05毫克/千克)、小米(铁-1.56毫克/千克)和土豆(锌-167毫克/千克)相比,有机芝麻(铁-3.12毫克/千克)、有机小米(铁-2.19毫克/千克)和有机土豆(锌-200毫克/千克)中的微量元素含量更高。
本调查得出结论,通过有机耕作,以最少的投入和最大的产量可以生产出营养成分最佳的作物。