Interdisciplinary School of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada.
Centre for Healthcare Resilience and Implementation Science, Australian Institute of Health Innovation, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2024 Jan 30;22(1):19. doi: 10.1186/s12961-024-01104-y.
Youth experiencing homelessness (YEH) suffer from poorer physical and mental health outcomes than stably housed youth. Additionally, YEH are forced to navigate fragmented health and social service systems on their own, where they often get lost between systems when transitioning or post-discharge. Inevitably, YEH require support with health system navigation and healthcare coordination. The aim of this study is to understand interactions within and between the emergency youth shelter (EYS) and health systems that affect healthcare coordination for YEH in Toronto, Canada, and how these interactions can be targeted to improve healthcare coordination for YEH.
This study is part of a larger qualitative case study informed by the framework for transformative systems change. To understand interactions in healthcare coordination for YEH within and between the EYS and health systems, we developed a causal loop diagram (CLD) using in-depth interview data from 24 key informants at various levels of both systems. Open and focused codes developed during analysis using Charmaz's constructivist grounded theory methodology were re-analysed to identify key variables, and links between them to create the CLD. The CLD was then validated by six stakeholders through a stakeholder forum.
The CLD illustrates six balancing and one reinforcing feedback loop in current healthcare coordination efforts within the EYS and health systems, respectively. Increasing EYS funding, building human resource capacity, strengthening inter and intra-systemic communication channels, and establishing strategic partnerships and formal referral pathways were identified among several other variables to be targeted to spiral positive change in healthcare coordination for YEH both within and between the EYS and health systems.
The CLD provides a conceptual overview of the independent and integrated systems through which decision-makers can prioritize and guide interventions to strengthen healthcare coordination within and between the EYS and health systems. Overall, our research findings suggest that key variables such as streamlining communication and improving staff-youth relationships be prioritized, as each of these acts interdependently and influences YEH's access, quality and coordination of healthcare.
与有稳定住所的年轻人相比,无家可归的年轻人(YEH)的身心健康状况更差。此外,YEH 被迫自行驾驭支离破碎的医疗和社会服务系统,在过渡或出院后,他们经常在系统之间迷失方向。不可避免的是,YEH 需要有人帮助他们了解医疗系统并协调医疗保健。本研究的目的是了解影响加拿大多伦多 YEH 医疗保健协调的青年紧急避难所(EYS)和卫生系统内部和之间的相互作用,以及如何针对这些相互作用来改善 YEH 的医疗保健协调。
本研究是一项更大的定性案例研究的一部分,该研究受变革性系统变革框架的启发。为了了解 EYS 和卫生系统内和之间 YEH 医疗保健协调的相互作用,我们使用来自两个系统各个层面的 24 名关键信息提供者的深入访谈数据,使用 Charmaz 的建构主义扎根理论方法开发了一个因果循环图(CLD)。在分析过程中开发的开放式和重点式代码,使用 Charmaz 的建构主义扎根理论方法进行了重新分析,以确定关键变量以及它们之间的联系,从而创建 CLD。然后,通过利益相关者论坛,由六名利益相关者对 CLD 进行了验证。
CLD 分别说明了 EYS 内和卫生系统内当前医疗保健协调工作中的六个平衡和一个增强反馈循环。增加 EYS 资金、建立人力资源能力、加强系统内和系统间的沟通渠道、建立战略伙伴关系和正式转诊途径,以及其他一些变量被确定为目标,以在 EYS 和卫生系统内和之间促进 YEH 医疗保健协调的积极变化。
CLD 提供了决策者可以通过该系统优先考虑和指导干预措施以加强 EYS 和卫生系统内和之间医疗保健协调的独立和综合系统的概念概述。总体而言,我们的研究结果表明,应优先考虑简化沟通和改善工作人员与年轻人的关系等关键变量,因为这些行为相互依存,并影响 YEH 获得、质量和协调医疗保健的能力。