Department of Paediatrics, division of Respiratory Medicine and Allergy, Erasmus MC - Sophia Children's Hospital, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
Department of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, Erasmus MC, University Medical Centre Rotterdam, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
BMJ Open Respir Res. 2024 Feb 2;11(1):e001505. doi: 10.1136/bmjresp-2022-001505.
The tobacco industry is accountable for an annual global death toll of approximately 8 million people and cigarette smoking is the foremost risk factor for several types of cancer. In addition, the tobacco industry has a long and controversial history of trying to influence scientific research and of engaging in other morally problematic practices. In September 2021, the respiratory community was alarmed by the takeover of Vectura Group (Vectura) by Philip Morris International. As a reaction to this acquisition, strict measures were imposed by the International Respiratory Societies to prohibit the involvement of Vectura in respiratory research and its participation in societies' activities. International Respiratory Societies argued that Vectura had become part of the tobacco industry due to this takeover and is, therefore, subject to the same rules and restrictions. From a healthcare and historical perspective, the reaction and imposed measures are very understandable. However, for researchers that were already affiliated with Vectura through long-standing agreements and for research that was funded by Vectura, the imposed measures have serious consequences. With this article, we provide an example of these consequences. By reflecting on this issue, we would like to start a conversation regarding the current measures and to encourage the respiratory community to begin thinking of a way to avoid these consequences in the future. In addition, we hope that with this conversation the Respiratory Societies can set an example for other medical societies on how to cope with possible morally tainted affiliations (eg, fast food companies, alcohol manufacturing companies) in the future.
烟草业每年造成全球约 800 万人死亡,吸烟是多种癌症的首要风险因素。此外,烟草业长期以来一直试图影响科学研究,并采取其他有道德问题的做法,其历史充满争议。2021 年 9 月,呼吸界对菲利普莫里斯国际(Philip Morris International)收购 Vectura 集团(Vectura)一事表示震惊。作为对此收购的回应,国际呼吸学会采取了严格措施,禁止 Vectura 参与呼吸研究及其在学会活动中的参与。国际呼吸学会认为,由于此次收购,Vectura 已成为烟草业的一部分,因此须遵守相同的规则和限制。从医疗保健和历史的角度来看,这种反应和实施的措施是非常可以理解的。然而,对于那些已经通过长期协议与 Vectura 有关联的研究人员,以及由 Vectura 资助的研究,实施的措施会产生严重后果。本文通过一个例子说明了这些后果。通过反思这个问题,我们希望就当前的措施展开讨论,并鼓励呼吸界开始思考如何在未来避免这些后果。此外,我们希望通过这次对话,呼吸学会可以为其他医学学会树立一个榜样,说明如何应对未来可能存在道德污点的关联(例如,快餐公司、酒精制造公司)。