Department of Palliative Medicine, Division of Surgery, Akershus University Hospital, Lørenskog, Norway.
Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
J Palliat Med. 2024 Jun;27(6):742-748. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2023.0496. Epub 2024 Feb 5.
Global trigger tool (GTT) was developed for identification of patient harm. In palliative patients deterioration can be expected, and there are no data on whether cases classified as "patient harm" actually represents a potential for improved patient safety. The primary aim was to test the performance and suitability of GTT in palliative care patients. The secondary aim was to pilot triggers for substandard palliative care. GTT was applied in 113 consecutive patients at a palliative ward at a Norwegian university hospital. Cases of patient harm were further evaluated to decide if the case was (a) a natural part of the disease trajectory or (b) a foreseeable consequence of treatment decisions. Potential triggers for substandard palliative care were tested. Two hundred twelve triggers (1.9 per hospitalization) and 26 cases of patient harm were identified. The positive predictive value (PPV) for identifying patient harm was 0.12. The most prevalent harm was pressure ulcers (8.8%). Of the 26 cases of patient harm, 6 cases were a natural part of the disease trajectory and 10 consequences of treatment decisions. In 21 (18%) patients triggers being piloted for substandard palliative care were present, identifying 9 cases of substandard palliative care. The highest PPV (0.67) was observed for "Cessation of antibiotics less than 5 days before death." With the exception of pressure ulcers, GTT triggers were infrequent or had a very poor PPV for patient harm. Triggers related to overtreatment might be suitable for identifying substandard palliative care.
全球触发工具(GTT)是为识别患者伤害而开发的。在姑息治疗患者中,病情恶化是可以预期的,而且没有关于被归类为“患者伤害”的病例实际上是否代表了提高患者安全性的潜力的数据。主要目的是测试 GTT 在姑息治疗患者中的性能和适用性。次要目的是为姑息治疗不足的触发因素进行试点。GTT 在挪威一所大学医院的姑息病房中应用于 113 例连续患者。进一步评估患者伤害病例,以确定该病例是否为 (a) 疾病轨迹的自然部分,或 (b) 治疗决策的可预见后果。测试了姑息治疗不足的潜在触发因素。确定了 212 个触发因素(每次住院 1.9 个)和 26 例患者伤害。识别患者伤害的阳性预测值(PPV)为 0.12。最常见的伤害是压疮(8.8%)。在 26 例患者伤害中,有 6 例是疾病轨迹的自然部分,有 10 例是治疗决策的后果。在 21 名(18%)接受姑息治疗不足触发因素试点的患者中,有 9 例姑息治疗不足。(0.67)最高的 PPV 观察到“在死亡前不到 5 天停止使用抗生素”。除了压疮外,GTT 触发因素对患者伤害的频率较低或 PPV 非常低。与过度治疗相关的触发因素可能适合识别姑息治疗不足。