Pio Luca, Gentilino Valerio, Macchini Francesco, Scarpa Alberto Attilio, Lo Piccolo Roberto, Conforti Andrea, Ratta Alberto, Guanà Riccardo, Molinaro Francesco, Costanzo Sara, Riccipetitoni Giovanna, Lisi Gabriele, Midrio Paola, Tocchioni Francesca, Cobellis Giovannii, Volpe Andrea, Zolpi Elisa, Morandi Anna, Ciardini Enrico, Vella Claudio, Grella Maria Giovanna, Sergio Maria, Guida Edoardo, Nanni Lorenzo, Ceccanti Silvia, Di Benedetto Vincenzo, Cheli Maurizio, Garzi Alfredo, Nobili Maria, Gabriele Valeria, Boroni Giovanni, Incerti Filippo, Zampieri Nicola, Cacciaguerra Sebastiano, Ceccarelli Pier Luca, Escolino Maria, Briganti Vito, Gori Davide, Esposito Ciro, Gamba Piergiorgio, Gennari Fabrizio, Inserra Alessandro, Dall'Igna Patrizia, Romeo Carmelo, Bagolan Pietro, Bleve Cosimo, Chiarenza Fabio, Morini Francesco, Pelizzo Gloria, Torre Michele
Pediatric Thoracic and Airway Surgery, IRCCS Giannina Gaslini, Genoa, Italy.
Department of Surgery, MS133, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, 262 Danny Thomas Place, Memphis, TN, 38105-3678, USA.
Pediatr Surg Int. 2024 Feb 10;40(1):53. doi: 10.1007/s00383-024-05635-x.
Over the years, congenital lung malformations (CLM) management remains a controversial topic in pediatric thoracic surgery. The Italian Society of Pediatric Surgery performed a national survey to study the current management variability among centers, trying to define national guidelines and a standardized approach of children with congenital lung malformations.
Following a National Society approval, an electronic survey including 35 items on post-natal management was designed, focusing on surgical, anesthesiology, radiology and pneumology aspects. The survey was conducted contacting all pediatric surgical units performing thoracic surgery.
39 pediatric surgery units (97.5%) participated in the study. 13 centers (33.3%) were classified as high-volume (Group A), while 26 centers (66.7%) were low volume (Group B). Variances in diagnostic imaging protocols were observed, with Group A performing fewer CT scans compared to Group B (p = 0.012). Surgical indications favored operative approaches for asymptomatic CLM and pulmonary sequestrations in both groups, while a wait-and-see approach was common for congenital lobar emphysema. Surgical timing for asymptomatic CLM differed significantly, with most high-volume centers operating on patients younger than 12 months (p = 0.02). Thoracoscopy was the preferred approach for asymptomatic CLM in most of centers, while postoperative long-term follow-up was not performed in most of the centers.
Thoracoscopic approach seems uniform in asymptomatic CLM patients and variable in symptomatic children. Lack of uniformity in surgical timing and preoperative imaging assessment has been identified as key areas to establish a common national pattern of care for CLM.
多年来,先天性肺畸形(CLM)的管理一直是小儿胸外科领域一个颇具争议的话题。意大利小儿外科学会开展了一项全国性调查,以研究各中心当前管理方式的差异,试图为先天性肺畸形患儿制定国家指南和标准化治疗方法。
经全国学会批准,设计了一项包含35项关于产后管理内容的电子调查问卷,重点关注外科、麻醉学、放射学和肺病学方面。通过联系所有开展胸外科手术的小儿外科单位来进行这项调查。
39个小儿外科单位(97.5%)参与了该研究。13个中心(33.3%)被归类为高手术量中心(A组),而26个中心(66.7%)为低手术量中心(B组)。观察到诊断成像方案存在差异,A组进行的CT扫描次数少于B组(p = 0.012)。两组对于无症状CLM和肺隔离症的手术指征都倾向于手术治疗,而对于先天性大叶性肺气肿则普遍采用观察等待的方法。无症状CLM的手术时机差异显著,大多数高手术量中心对12个月以下的患儿进行手术(p = 0.02)。在大多数中心,胸腔镜检查是无症状CLM的首选治疗方法,而大多数中心未进行术后长期随访。
胸腔镜治疗方法在无症状CLM患者中似乎较为统一,而在有症状患儿中则存在差异。手术时机和术前影像学评估缺乏一致性已被确定为建立CLM全国统一护理模式的关键领域。