Department of Preventive and Community Dentistry, The University of Iowa College of Dentistry and Dental Clinics, Iowa City, Iowa, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2024 Jun;88(6):840-847. doi: 10.1002/jdd.13496. Epub 2024 Feb 16.
The COVID-19 pandemic required a rapid transition to online education, including simulations. The current study identified students' perceptions of communicating with standardized patients in a virtual setting.
This qualitative study thematically analyzed 485 reflections submitted by 248 students between Spring 2020 and Spring 2022. Statements describing both the virtual medium and dyadic interactions between students and patients were coded for emergent themes and also coded as positive (facilitative) or negative (critical).
Four themes emerged from the data related to the virtual medium: impact on nonverbal communication, patient engagement/rapport, presentation aids, and listening. Within these broad themes, 13 subthemes were identified, nine of which were negative/critical. Technology problems were specifically identified as compromising both engagement and listening. Even when technology worked well, students noted that it reduced the number of message cues received from the patient and complicated the process of sending cues (e.g., by requiring students to look away from a patient's face to make "eye contact" through a camera).
Overall, students were critical of Zoom's impact on dyadic factors with standardized patients. However, they did acknowledge some positive aspects regarding the technology. These findings provide a foundation to consider when teaching students how to communicate effectively via teledentistry.
COVID-19 大流行要求迅速转向在线教育,包括模拟教学。本研究旨在确定学生对在虚拟环境中与标准化患者进行沟通的看法。
本定性研究对 2020 年春季至 2022 年春季期间 248 名学生提交的 485 份反思报告进行了主题分析。对描述虚拟媒介以及学生与患者之间的二元互动的陈述进行了编码,以确定出现的主题,并根据其是积极(促进)还是消极(批评)进行分类。
数据中出现了与虚拟媒介相关的四个主题:对非言语交流的影响、患者参与/融洽程度、演示辅助工具和倾听。在这些广泛的主题中,确定了 13 个子主题,其中 9 个是负面/批评性的。技术问题被特别确定为影响参与度和倾听。即使技术运行良好,学生也指出,它减少了从患者那里收到的信息提示数量,并使发送提示的过程变得复杂(例如,要求学生从患者的面部移开视线,通过摄像头进行“眼神交流”)。
总体而言,学生对 Zoom 对与标准化患者的二元因素的影响持批评态度。然而,他们确实承认该技术具有一些积极方面。这些发现为教授学生如何通过远程牙科进行有效沟通提供了基础。