Mortazavi Mahshid, Garg Shikha, Waite T David
UNSW Water Research Centre, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia.
UNSW Water Research Centre, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia.
J Hazard Mater. 2024 Apr 15;468:133736. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2024.133736. Epub 2024 Feb 7.
The peroxone process (O/HO) is reported to be a more effective process than the ozonation process due to an increased rate of generation of hydroxyl radicals (OH) and inhibition of bromate (BrO) formation which is otherwise formed on ozonation of bromide containing waters. However, the trade-off between the HO dosage required for minimization of BrO formation and effective pollutant removal has not been clearly delineated. In this study, employing experimental investigations as well as chemical modelling, we show that the concentration of HO required to achieve maximum pollutant removal may not be the same as that required for minimization of BrO formation. At the HO dosage required to minimize BrO formation (<10 µg/L), only pollutants with high to moderate reactivity towards O and OH are effectively removed. For pollutants with low reactivity towards O/OH, high O (O:DOC>>1 g/g) and high HO dosages (O:HO ∼1 (g/g)) are required for minimizing BrO formation along with effective pollutant removal which may result in a very high residual of HO in the effluent, causing secondary pollution. On balance, we conclude that the peroxone process is not effective for the removal of low reactivity micropollutants if minimization of BrO formation is also required.
据报道,过氧臭氧工艺(O/HO)比臭氧化工艺更有效,因为其羟基自由基(OH)的生成速率增加,且抑制了溴酸盐(BrO)的形成,而在含溴水的臭氧化过程中会生成溴酸盐。然而,使溴酸盐形成最小化所需的HO剂量与有效去除污染物之间的权衡尚未明确界定。在本研究中,通过实验研究和化学建模,我们表明实现最大污染物去除所需的HO浓度可能与使溴酸盐形成最小化所需的浓度不同。在使溴酸盐形成最小化所需的HO剂量(<10μg/L)下,只有对O和OH具有高至中等反应活性的污染物才能被有效去除。对于对O/OH反应活性低的污染物,为了使溴酸盐形成最小化并有效去除污染物,需要高O(O:DOC>>1g/g)和高HO剂量(O:HO ∼1 (g/g)),这可能导致流出物中HO残留量非常高,造成二次污染。权衡之下,我们得出结论,如果还需要使溴酸盐形成最小化,过氧臭氧工艺对于去除低反应活性的微污染物是无效的。