Lopez Barreto Brittany N, Hestir Erin L, Lee Christine M, Beutel Marc W
Environmental Systems Graduate Group Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering University of California Merced Merced CA USA.
Center for Information Technology Research in the Interest of Society The Banatao Institute University of California Merced Merced CA USA.
Geohealth. 2024 Feb 23;8(2):e2023GH000941. doi: 10.1029/2023GH000941. eCollection 2024 Feb.
Cyanobacterial harmful algal blooms (cyanoHABs) can harm people, animals, and affect consumptive and recreational use of inland waters. Monitoring cyanoHABs is often limited. However, chlorophyll- (chl-) is a common water quality metric and has been shown to have a relationship with cyanobacteria. The World Health Organization (WHO) recently updated their previous 1999 cyanoHAB guidance values (GVs) to be more practical by basing the GVs on chl- concentration rather than cyanobacterial counts. This creates an opportunity for widespread cyanoHAB monitoring based on chl- proxies, with satellite remote sensing (SRS) being a potentially powerful tool. We used Sentinel-2 (S2) and Sentinel-3 (S3) to map chl- and cyanobacteria, respectively, classified chl- values according to WHO GVs, and then compared them to cyanotoxin advisories issued by the California Department of Water Resources (DWR) at San Luis Reservoir, key infrastructure in California's water system. We found reasonably high rates of total agreement between advisories by DWR and SRS, however rates of agreement varied for S2 based on algorithm. Total agreement was 83% for S3, and 52%-79% for S2. False positive and false negative rates for S3 were 12% and 23%, respectively. S2 had 12%-80% false positive rate and 0%-38% false negative rate, depending on algorithm. Using SRS-based chl- GVs as an early indicator for possible exposure advisories and as a trigger for in situ sampling may be effective to improve public health warnings. Implementing SRS for cyanoHAB monitoring could fill temporal data gaps and provide greater spatial information not available from in situ measurements alone.
蓝藻有害藻华(cyanoHABs)会危害人类、动物,并影响内陆水域的消费和娱乐用途。对cyanoHABs的监测往往受到限制。然而,叶绿素(chl-)是一种常见的水质指标,已被证明与蓝藻有关。世界卫生组织(WHO)最近更新了其1999年的cyanoHAB指导值(GVs),使其更具实用性,即将GVs基于chl-浓度而非蓝藻数量。这为基于chl-替代指标进行广泛的cyanoHAB监测创造了机会,卫星遥感(SRS)是一种潜在的强大工具。我们分别使用哨兵-2(S2)和哨兵-3(S3)绘制chl-和蓝藻的地图,根据WHO GVs对chl-值进行分类,然后将其与加利福尼亚州水资源部(DWR)在加利福尼亚州水系统的关键基础设施圣路易斯水库发布的蓝藻毒素建议进行比较。我们发现DWR的建议与SRS之间的总体一致率相当高,然而,基于算法的Sentinel-2的一致率有所不同。S3的总体一致率为83%,S2为52%-79%。S3的假阳性率和假阴性率分别为12%和23%。根据算法,S2的假阳性率为12%-80%,假阴性率为0%-38%。将基于SRS的chl- GVs用作可能的接触建议的早期指标以及现场采样的触发因素,可能有效地改善公共卫生警告。实施SRS进行cyanoHAB监测可以填补时间数据空白,并提供仅通过现场测量无法获得的更大空间信息。