Social and Health Outcomes Research and Evaluation (SHORE), SHORE and Whariki Research Centre College of Health, Massey University, Auckland, New Zealand.
Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Addiction. 2024 May;119(5):855-862. doi: 10.1111/add.16435. Epub 2024 Feb 26.
Quantifying the health burden of alcohol has largely focused upon harm to drinkers, which is an underestimate. There is a growing literature on alcohol's harm to others (HTO), but it lacks the systematic transfer of HTO into a comparative risk assessment framework. This study calculated disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD), interpersonal violence and traffic injury due to another's drinking.
This study is a disease burden analysis, using modelling of DALYs for New Zealand in 2018.
The study took place among the Aotearoa/New Zealand population in 2018.
The involvement of others' drinking was obtained from prevalence, alcohol-attributable fraction studies and administrative data. Disability weights (DW) for FASD were adapted from fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) weights using a Beta-Pert probability distribution; for interpersonal injury, DWs used hospital events linked with injury compensation; for traffic injury, DWs used hospital events. Populations were stratified by ethnicity, age group and gender. A descriptive comparison was made with a previous estimate of DALYs for drinkers.
In 2018, 78 277 healthy life years were lost in Aotearoa/New Zealand due to alcohol's HTO. The main contributor (90.3%) was FASD, then traffic crashes (6.3%) and interpersonal violence (3.4%). The indigenous population, Māori, was impacted at a higher rate (DALYs among Māori were 25 per 1000 population; among non-Māori 15 per 1000 population). The burden of HTO was greater than that to drinkers (DALYs HTO = 78 277; DALYs drinkers = 60 174).
Disability from fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD) appears to be a major contributor to alcohol's harm to others in Aotearoa/New Zealand. Taking FASD into account, the health burden of harm to others is larger than harm to the drinker in Aotearoa/New Zealand, and ethnicity differences show inequity in harm to others. Quantification of the burden of harm informs the value of implementing effective alcohol policies and should include the full range of harms.
评估酒精对健康的影响主要集中在对饮酒者的伤害上,而这只是一个低估。越来越多的文献研究了酒精对他人的危害(HTO),但缺乏将 HTO 系统地纳入比较风险评估框架的研究。本研究计算了胎儿酒精谱系障碍(FASD)、人际暴力和因他人饮酒导致的交通伤害的伤残调整生命年(DALYs)。
本研究是一项疾病负担分析,使用新西兰 2018 年的模型进行 DALYs 计算。
该研究在新西兰的奥特亚罗瓦/新西兰人口中进行。
他人饮酒的参与情况通过患病率、归因于酒精的比例研究和行政数据获得。FASD 的残疾权重(DW)是通过 Beta-Pert 概率分布从胎儿酒精综合征(FAS)权重中改编而来的;对于人际伤害,DW 是通过与伤害赔偿相关的医院事件获得的;对于交通伤害,DW 是通过医院事件获得的。人群按种族、年龄组和性别分层。与之前对饮酒者 DALYs 的估计进行了描述性比较。
2018 年,由于酒精对他人的 HTO,新西兰损失了 78277 个健康生命年。主要贡献者(90.3%)是 FASD,其次是交通碰撞(6.3%)和人际暴力(3.4%)。原住民,毛利人,受到的影响更大(毛利人每 1000 人中有 25 个 DALYs;非毛利人每 1000 人中有 15 个 DALYs)。HTO 的负担大于饮酒者(HTO 的 DALYs=78277;饮酒者的 DALYs=60174)。
胎儿酒精谱系障碍(FASD)导致的残疾似乎是新西兰酒精对他人造成伤害的主要原因。考虑到 FASD,对他人造成的伤害的健康负担大于对饮酒者的伤害,而且种族差异表明对他人造成的伤害存在不公平现象。伤害负担的量化为实施有效的酒精政策提供了价值信息,应包括所有伤害类型。