Miles Randy C, Lourenco Ana P, Baird Grayson L, Roy Ishita T, Choi Paul H S, Lehman Constance, Lamb Leslie R
Massachusetts General Hospital, Department of Radiology, Boston, MA, USA.
Rhode Island Hospital, Department of Diagnostic Imaging, Providence, RI, USA.
J Breast Imaging. 2021 Sep 16;3(5):564-571. doi: 10.1093/jbi/wbab053.
To assess understandability, actionability, and readability of online patient educational materials (OPEM) related to breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA-ALCL).
Search volumes for query terms related to BIA-ALCL including "breast implant associated lymphoma," "breast implant associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma," and "BIA-ALCL" were analyzed in one-week increments and normalized to total Google search volume. The same terms were then queried using an online search engine to identify commonly accessed OPEM on this topic. Understandability and actionability of OPEM were evaluated using the Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool. Grade-level readability was determined using generalized estimating equations, with observations nested within readability metrics from each website. All interval estimates were calculated for 95% confidence.
Overall, 24 websites were identified based on search parameters. Of these websites, 11 (45.8%) met criteria for understandability, and 1 (4.2%) met criteria for actionability. Overall, readability ranged from 10.2 to 17.3 for all websites with an average grade level readability of 12.4; 0 websites were written at or below a sixth-grade reading level. Government websites had the highest average grade reading level at 14.0, followed by commercial websites at 13.2, nonprofit websites at 12.0, and then academic/hospital-based websites at 11.5.
The quality of available OPEM on BIA-ALCL is limited. Future development of OPEM should be designed with the goal of improving both comprehension and actionability to help reduce patient anxiety and unnecessary clinical appointments related to this disease.
评估与乳房植入物相关间变性大细胞淋巴瘤(BIA-ALCL)相关的在线患者教育材料(OPEM)的可理解性、可操作性和可读性。
以一周为增量分析与BIA-ALCL相关的查询词的搜索量,包括“乳房植入物相关淋巴瘤”、“乳房植入物相关间变性大细胞淋巴瘤”和“BIA-ALCL”,并将其标准化为谷歌总搜索量。然后使用在线搜索引擎查询相同的词,以识别关于该主题的常见访问的OPEM。使用患者教育材料评估工具评估OPEM的可理解性和可操作性。使用广义估计方程确定年级可读性,观察值嵌套在每个网站的可读性指标中。所有区间估计均计算为95%置信度。
总体而言,根据搜索参数确定了24个网站。在这些网站中,11个(45.8%)符合可理解性标准,1个(4.2%)符合可操作性标准。总体而言,所有网站的可读性范围为10.2至17.3,平均年级可读性为12.4;没有网站的写作水平达到或低于六年级阅读水平。政府网站的平均年级阅读水平最高,为14.0,其次是商业网站,为13.2,非营利网站为12.0,然后是学术/医院网站,为11.5。
关于BIA-ALCL的现有OPEM质量有限。OPEM的未来开发应以提高理解性和可操作性为目标进行设计,以帮助减少患者的焦虑和与此疾病相关的不必要的临床预约。