Whitman N, Eyre S
Fam Med. 1985 Jan-Feb;17(1):26-8.
Although it is important to medical school faculty that they publish articles, little has been done to study the process of submitting manuscripts to journals. Specifically, the authors of this study surveyed authors in nine journals read by family medicine teachers to see if their published articles previously had been rejected by other journals. Based on 517 responses from 541 authors (96% response rate), the authors learned that the New England Journal of Medicine had the highest "not previously rejected" rate of 98% and the Journal of the American Medical Association had the lowest rate of 68%. Overall, 11% of the articles published in the eight other journals in the study previously had been rejected by NEJM. It might be interesting for an author whose manuscript is rejected to know the rates of rejection and publication of various journals.
尽管医学院教员发表文章很重要,但在研究向期刊投稿的过程方面却做得很少。具体而言,本研究的作者对家庭医学教师阅读的九种期刊的作者进行了调查,以了解他们发表的文章之前是否被其他期刊拒绝过。基于541位作者的517份回复(回复率为96%),作者了解到《新英格兰医学杂志》的“未曾被拒稿”率最高,为98%,而《美国医学会杂志》的该比率最低,为68%。总体而言,该研究中其他八种期刊发表的文章中有11%之前被《新英格兰医学杂志》拒稿。对于手稿被拒的作者来说,了解各种期刊的拒稿率和发表率可能会很有意思。