Oleru Olachi O, Rohde Christine H
SUNY Downstate Health Sciences University, New York, NY, USA.
New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York, NY, USA.
Plast Surg (Oakv). 2024 Feb;32(1):54-63. doi: 10.1177/22925503221088845. Epub 2022 Mar 23.
Gender-affirming surgery is becoming more common among reconstructive surgeons. Bibliometric analyses are statistical evaluations of published scientific correspondence and are a validated method of measuring influence in the scientific community. As no such bibliometric analysis has been done as of yet, the purpose of this study is to identify the characteristics of the 50 most-cited peer-reviewed articles on gender-affirming surgery. The Scopus abstract and citation database was utilized in April 2020 to search for English-language publications related to gender-affirming surgery. The 50 most-cited publications that met inclusion criteria were reviewed for various metric tabulations. The 50 publications have been cited a total of 4402 times. Thirty-one (62%) were published in 2000 or later. Phalloplasty was the most discussed surgical technique, and 18 of the articles focused on female-to-male (FtM) patients. Case series (46%) and review articles (24%) were most common and there were no Level I or Level II studies. The Netherlands contributed the most, with 13 articles. Among the most frequent keywords in the 50 abstracts were "flap" and "complication". The earliest author keywords used were "transsexual" and "sex reassignment". The keyword usage in these abstracts over time seems to follow the trend of a more socially inclusive lexicon. A focus on studies with a higher level of evidence may optimize surgeon education and more appropriately guide clinical practice. This study reveals that the most influential and commonly referenced studies may not be sufficient to appropriately guide clinical practices.
性别确认手术在整形外科医生中越来越普遍。文献计量分析是对已发表的科学通信进行的统计评估,是衡量科学界影响力的一种有效方法。由于尚未进行此类文献计量分析,本研究的目的是确定关于性别确认手术被引用次数最多的50篇同行评议文章的特征。2020年4月利用Scopus摘要和引文数据库搜索与性别确认手术相关的英文出版物。对符合纳入标准的被引用次数最多的50篇出版物进行了各种指标统计。这50篇出版物总共被引用了4402次。其中31篇(62%)发表于2000年或之后。阴茎成形术是讨论最多的手术技术,18篇文章关注女性变男性(FtM)患者。病例系列(46%)和综述文章(24%)最为常见,没有一级或二级研究。荷兰贡献的文章最多,有13篇。50篇摘要中最常见的关键词包括“皮瓣移植”和“并发症”。最早使用的作者关键词是“变性者”和“性别重置”。这些摘要中关键词的使用随着时间的推移似乎遵循了词汇更加具有社会包容性的趋势。关注具有更高证据水平的研究可能会优化外科医生的教育,并更恰当地指导临床实践。本研究表明,最具影响力和最常被引用的研究可能不足以恰当地指导临床实践。