Zoughaib William S, Fry Madison J, Singhal Ahaan, Coggan Andrew R
Department of Kinesiology, School of Health & Human Sciences, Indiana University Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN, United States.
School of Medicine, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, IN, United States.
Front Nutr. 2024 Feb 20;11:1347242. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2024.1347242. eCollection 2024.
This mini-review summarizes the comparative effects of different sources of dietary nitrate (NO), beetroot juice (BRJ) and nitrate salts (NIT), on physiological function and exercise capacity. Our objectives were to determine whether BRJ is superior to NIT in enhancing exercise-related outcomes, and to explore the potential contribution of other putatively beneficial compounds in BRJ beyond NO. We conducted a comparative analysis of recent studies focused on the impact of BRJ versus NIT on submaximal oxygen consumption (VO), endurance performance, adaptations to training, and recovery from muscle-damaging exercise. While both NO sources provide benefits, there is some evidence that BRJ may offer additional advantages, specifically in reducing VO during high-intensity exercise, magnifying performance improvements with training, and improving recovery post-exercise. These reported differences could be due to the hypothesized antioxidant and/or anti-inflammatory properties of BRJ resulting from the rich spectrum of phytonutrients it contains. However, significant limitations to published studies directly comparing BRJ and NIT make it quite challenging to draw any firm conclusions. We provide recommendations to help guide further research into the important question of whether there is more to the story of BRJ than just NO.
本综述总结了不同膳食硝酸盐(NO)来源,即甜菜根汁(BRJ)和硝酸盐类(NIT),对生理功能和运动能力的比较影响。我们的目的是确定BRJ在改善运动相关结果方面是否优于NIT,并探索BRJ中除NO之外其他假定有益化合物的潜在作用。我们对近期研究进行了比较分析,这些研究聚焦于BRJ与NIT对次最大摄氧量(VO)、耐力表现、训练适应性以及肌肉损伤运动后的恢复的影响。虽然两种NO来源都有益处,但有证据表明BRJ可能具有额外优势,特别是在高强度运动期间降低VO、增强训练带来的性能提升以及改善运动后恢复方面。这些报道的差异可能归因于BRJ所含丰富植物营养素所具有的假定抗氧化和/或抗炎特性。然而,已发表的直接比较BRJ和NIT的研究存在显著局限性,这使得很难得出任何确凿结论。我们提供了一些建议,以帮助指导进一步研究这个重要问题,即BRJ的作用是否不仅仅在于NO。