World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Healthier Systems Ltd., Streatley, United Kingdom.
Front Public Health. 2024 Feb 21;12:1303786. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1303786. eCollection 2024.
Multisectoral action is a central component of the global response to the rising prevalence of non-communicable diseases (NCDs). In this paper we aimed to unpack the definition of multisectoral action and provide an overview of the historical context, challenges, and recommendations alongside three country case studies: salt reduction in the UK, tobacco legislation in Nigeria, and regulation of edible oils in Iran.
We used an iterative review process to select three country case studies from a list of 20 potential cases previously identified by WHO. At our third round of review we unanimously agreed to focus on salt reduction in the UK, tobacco regulation in Nigeria, and edible oil regulation in Iran as these represented rich cases on diverse risk factors from three different world regions that we felt offered important lessons. We conducted literature reviews to identify further data for each case study.
Across the three studies a number of important themes emerged. We found that multisectoral approaches demand the often difficult reconciliation of competing and conflicting values and priorities. Across our three chosen cases, commercial interests and free trade agreements were the most common obstacles to successful multisectoral strategies. We found that early consultative stakeholder engagement and strong political and bureaucratic leadership were necessary for success.
The complex multi-rooted nature of NCDs requires a multisectoral approach, but the inevitable conflicts that this entails requires careful navigation.
多部门行动是应对非传染性疾病(NCD)流行率上升的全球应对措施的核心组成部分。本文旨在剖析多部门行动的定义,并概述其历史背景、挑战和建议,同时辅以三个国家案例研究:英国的减盐行动、尼日利亚的烟草立法以及伊朗的食用油监管。
我们采用迭代审查流程,从世卫组织先前确定的 20 个潜在案例中选择了三个国家案例研究。在我们的第三轮审查中,我们一致同意重点关注英国的减盐行动、尼日利亚的烟草监管和伊朗的食用油监管,因为这些案例代表了来自三个不同世界区域的不同风险因素的丰富案例,我们认为这些案例提供了重要的经验教训。我们进行了文献综述,以确定每个案例研究的更多数据。
在这三个研究中,出现了一些重要的主题。我们发现,多部门方法需要经常协调相互竞争和冲突的价值观和优先事项。在我们选择的三个案例中,商业利益和自由贸易协定是成功的多部门战略的最常见障碍。我们发现,早期的协商利益相关者参与和强有力的政治和官僚领导是成功的必要条件。
NCD 的复杂多根源性质需要采取多部门方法,但这必然会产生冲突,需要谨慎应对。