Speer Tillmann, Mühlbradt Thomas, Unger Helga, Fastner Christian, Schröder Stefan
Klinik für Anästhesiologie, Klinikum Itzehoe, Robert-Koch-Straße 2, 25524, Itzehoe, Deutschland.
FOM Hochschule für Oekonomie & Management, Essen, Deutschland.
Anaesthesiologie. 2024 Apr;73(4):232-243. doi: 10.1007/s00101-024-01390-9. Epub 2024 Mar 8.
Various professional groups are involved in the daily work of the central operating room with the aim of providing the best possible treatment for each individual using modern medical technology (sociotechnical system) in a cost-effective manner. Ensuring perioperative patient safety is of particular importance. At the same time, the efficient use of the central operating room is essential for the economic success of a hospital. Preoperative preparation is a complex process with many substeps that are often difficult to manage. Historically, the focus has been on retrospective learning from errors and incidents. More recent approaches take a systemic view. A central idea is to consider the mostly positive course of treatment and the adjustments to daily work that are currently required by the people involved (Safety-II). By taking greater account of how the many components of the system interact, processes can be better understood and specific measures derived. This strengthens the system's ability to adapt to changes and disturbances, thus ensuring that goals are achieved. The functional resonance analysis method (FRAM) is an internationally recognized method for modelling work as done compared to work as imagined. This paper presents the application of FRAM to preoperative preparation in a major regional hospital.
Is FRAM suitable for improving process understanding in preoperative preparation?
An interdisciplinary project team identified relevant functions of preoperative preparation through document analysis and walkthroughs. Based on this, more than 30 guided interviews were conducted with functionaries. The results were presented graphically and specific information, such as safety-related statements or reasons for the variability of functions, were also presented textually. In the next phase, statements were evaluated and compared with the target model and the job descriptions.
The FRAM revealed the process as a complex network of relationships. During the modelling process, a varying degree of centrality and variability of certain functions became apparent. From the observations, the project team selected those with high relevance for patient safety and for the efficiency of the overall process in order to prioritize starting points for deriving measures to increase resilience. These starting points relate either to single functions, such as surgical site marking or to multiple functions that are variable in their execution, such as delays due to nonsynchronized duty times.
The FRAM conducted provides valuable new insights into the functioning of complex sociotechnical systems that go far beyond classical linear methods. The awareness of operational processes gained and the resulting dynamic view of interactions within the system enable specific measures to be derived that promote resilient behavior and reduce critical variability, thus contributing to increased patient safety and efficiency.
多个专业团队参与中央手术室的日常工作,旨在以具有成本效益的方式利用现代医疗技术(社会技术系统)为每个患者提供尽可能最佳的治疗。确保围手术期患者安全尤为重要。同时,中央手术室的高效利用对医院的经济成功至关重要。术前准备是一个复杂的过程,包含许多往往难以管理的子步骤。从历史上看,重点一直是从错误和事件中进行回顾性学习。最近的方法则采取系统的观点。一个核心思想是考虑治疗过程大多积极的情况以及相关人员当前对日常工作所做的调整(安全-II)。通过更多地考虑系统的许多组成部分如何相互作用,可以更好地理解流程并得出具体措施。这增强了系统适应变化和干扰的能力,从而确保目标得以实现。功能共振分析方法(FRAM)是一种国际认可的将实际完成的工作与设想的工作进行建模的方法。本文介绍了FRAM在一家大型地区医院术前准备中的应用。
FRAM是否适合增进对术前准备流程的理解?
一个跨学科项目团队通过文档分析和流程演练确定了术前准备的相关功能。在此基础上,对相关人员进行了30多次有引导的访谈。结果以图形方式呈现,同时也以文字形式呈现了具体信息,如与安全相关的陈述或功能变异性的原因。在下一阶段,对陈述进行评估并与目标模型和工作描述进行比较。
FRAM将该流程揭示为一个复杂的关系网络。在建模过程中,某些功能的中心性和变异性程度各不相同。从观察结果来看,项目团队挑选出那些与患者安全和整个流程效率高度相关的功能,以便优先确定推导提高恢复力措施的起点。这些起点要么涉及单个功能,如手术部位标记,要么涉及执行过程中可变的多个功能,如由于值班时间不同步导致的延误。
所实施的FRAM为复杂社会技术系统的运行提供了有价值的新见解,远远超出了传统的线性方法。所获得的对操作流程的认识以及由此产生的对系统内相互作用的动态观点使得能够得出促进恢复力行为并减少关键变异性的具体措施,从而有助于提高患者安全和效率。