Gao Jiayu, Zhao Yahui, Wang Ziwei, Liu Fei, Chen Xuan, Mo Jialin, Jiang Yifei, Liu Yongqiang, Tian Peiyi, Li Yanong, Deng Kaiwen, Qi Xueling, Han Dongming, Liu Zijia, Yang Zhengtao, Chen Yixi, Tang Yujie, Li Chunde, Liu Hailong, Li Jiankang, Jiang Tao
BGI-Shenzhen, Shenzhen, China.
Yidu Central Hospital of Weifang, Weifang, China.
Animal Model Exp Med. 2025 Mar;8(3):458-472. doi: 10.1002/ame2.12399. Epub 2024 Mar 13.
Medulloblastoma (MB) is one of the most common malignant brain tumors that mainly affect children. Various approaches have been used to model MB to facilitate investigating tumorigenesis. This study aims to compare the recapitulation of MB between subcutaneous patient-derived xenograft (sPDX), intracranial patient-derived xenograft (iPDX), and genetically engineered mouse models (GEMM) at the single-cell level.
We obtained primary human sonic hedgehog (SHH) and group 3 (G3) MB samples from six patients. For each patient specimen, we developed two sPDX and iPDX models, respectively. Three Patch+/- GEMM models were also included for sequencing. Single-cell RNA sequencing was performed to compare gene expression profiles, cellular composition, and functional pathway enrichment. Bulk RNA-seq deconvolution was performed to compare cellular composition across models and human samples.
Our results showed that the sPDX tumor model demonstrated the highest correlation to the overall transcriptomic profiles of primary human tumors at the single-cell level within the SHH and G3 subgroups, followed by the GEMM model and iPDX. The GEMM tumor model was able to recapitulate all subpopulations of tumor microenvironment (TME) cells that can be clustered in human SHH tumors, including a higher proportion of tumor-associated astrocytes and immune cells, and an additional cluster of vascular endothelia when compared to human SHH tumors.
This study was the first to compare experimental models for MB at the single-cell level, providing value insights into model selection for different research purposes. sPDX and iPDX are suitable for drug testing and personalized therapy screenings, whereas GEMM models are valuable for investigating the interaction between tumor and TME cells.
髓母细胞瘤(MB)是最常见的主要影响儿童的恶性脑肿瘤之一。已采用多种方法对MB进行建模,以促进对肿瘤发生的研究。本研究旨在在单细胞水平上比较皮下患者来源异种移植模型(sPDX)、颅内患者来源异种移植模型(iPDX)和基因工程小鼠模型(GEMM)对MB的模拟情况。
我们从6例患者中获取了原发性人音猬因子(SHH)和第3组(G3)MB样本。对于每个患者标本,我们分别建立了两个sPDX和iPDX模型。还纳入了三个Patch+/- GEMM模型进行测序。进行单细胞RNA测序以比较基因表达谱、细胞组成和功能通路富集情况。进行批量RNA-seq反卷积以比较各模型与人类样本之间的细胞组成。
我们的结果表明,在SHH和G3亚组中,sPDX肿瘤模型在单细胞水平上与原发性人类肿瘤的整体转录组谱相关性最高,其次是GEMM模型和iPDX。GEMM肿瘤模型能够重现人类SHH肿瘤中可聚类的肿瘤微环境(TME)细胞的所有亚群,包括与人类SHH肿瘤相比比例更高的肿瘤相关星形胶质细胞和免疫细胞,以及另外一组血管内皮细胞。
本研究首次在单细胞水平上比较了MB的实验模型,为不同研究目的的模型选择提供了有价值的见解。sPDX和iPDX适用于药物测试和个性化治疗筛选,而GEMM模型对于研究肿瘤与TME细胞之间的相互作用具有重要价值。