Harrop Danielle L, Bryce Vivian, Kitchener Tanya, Grugan Sean, Renouf Sonia, Mitchell Scott, Hasking Gregory, Pauza Debra, Richards Gregory, Ng Arnold C T, Wang William Y S
Department of Cardiology, Princess Alexandra Hospital, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; Faculty of Medicine, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia.
Department of Cardiology, Princess Alexandra Hospital, Brisbane, QLD, Australia.
Lancet Glob Health. 2024 Apr;12(4):e623-e630. doi: 10.1016/S2214-109X(23)00601-0.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander (Indigenous) peoples with cardiac disease in Australia have worse outcomes than non-Indigenous people with cardiac disease. We hypothesised that the implementation of a culturally informed model of care for Indigenous patients hospitalised with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) would improve their clinical outcomes.
For this pre-post, quasi-experimental, interventional study, cohorts of Indigenous patients before and after the implementation of a model of care were compared. The novel, culturally informed, multidisciplinary-team model of care was a local programme of care developed to reduce morbidity and mortality from cardiac conditions among Indigenous Australians. All index admissions in the 24-month pre-implementation period (Jan 1 2013, to Dec 31, 2014) were analysed, as were all index admissions in the 12-month post-implementation period (Oct 1, 2015, to Sept 30, 2016). Comparisons were also made with non-Indigenous cohorts in the same timeframes. Admissions were excluded if the patient did not survive to hospital discharge. The study was conducted at Princess Alexandra Hospital, a tertiary hospital in metropolitan Brisbane (QLD, Australia). Data on presentation, comorbidities, investigations, treatment, and for outcomes were manually collected from a consolidated clinical information application. Mortality data were obtained from the Queensland Registry of Births, Deaths, and Marriages. The primary outcome was a composite of death, acute myocardial infarction, unplanned revascularisation, and cardiac readmission at 90 days after index admission, assessed in all patients.
The Indigenous cohorts included 199 patients admitted with ACS before the model of care was implemented (85 [43%] were female and 114 [57%] were male) and 119 admitted post-implementation (62 [52%] were female and 57 [48%] were male). The non-Indigenous cohorts included 440 patients with ACS before the model of care was implemented (140 [32%] were female and 300 [68%] were male) and 467 admitted post-implementation (143 [31%] were female and 324 [69%] were male). Compared with the pre-implementation group, Indigenous patients admitted post-implementation had a significant reduction in the primary outcome (67 [34%] of 199 vs 24 [20%] of 119; hazard ratio 0·60, 95% CI 0·40-0·90; p=0·012), which was driven by a reduction in unplanned cardiac readmissions (64 [32%] of 199 vs 21 [18%] of 119; 0·55, 0·35-0·85; p=0·0060). There was no significant change in non-Indigenous patients between the pre-implementation and post-implementation timeframes in the composite endpoint at 90 days (81 [18%] of 440 vs 93 [20%] of 467; 1·08, 0·83-1·41; p=0·54). Pre-implementation, there was significantly more incidence of the primary outcome in Indigenous patients than non-Indigenous patients (p<0·0001), with no significant difference in the post-implementation period (p=0·92).
Clinical outcomes for Indigenous patients admitted to a tertiary hospital in Australia improved after implementation of a culturally informed model of care, with a reduction in the disparity in incidence of primary endpoints that existed between Indigenous and non-Indigenous patients before implementation.
Queensland Department of Health Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Division (now First Nations Health Office).
在澳大利亚,患有心脏病的原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民(土著居民)的治疗结果比非土著心脏病患者更差。我们假设,为因急性冠状动脉综合征(ACS)住院的土著患者实施一种具有文化针对性的护理模式,将改善他们的临床治疗结果。
在这项前后对照、准实验性的干预研究中,对护理模式实施前后的土著患者队列进行了比较。这种新颖的、具有文化针对性的多学科团队护理模式是一项当地护理计划,旨在降低澳大利亚原住民心脏病的发病率和死亡率。分析了实施前24个月(2013年1月1日至2014年12月31日)的所有索引入院病例,以及实施后12个月(2015年10月1日至2016年9月30日)的所有索引入院病例。同时也与同一时间段的非土著队列进行了比较。如果患者未存活至出院,则排除该入院病例。该研究在亚历山德拉公主医院进行,这是一家位于澳大利亚布里斯班市的三级医院。关于患者就诊情况、合并症、检查、治疗及治疗结果的数据是从一个综合临床信息应用程序中手动收集的。死亡率数据来自昆士兰出生、死亡和婚姻登记处。主要结局是在所有患者中评估的索引入院后90天的死亡、急性心肌梗死、非计划血管重建和心脏再入院的综合情况。
土著队列中,在护理模式实施前有199例因ACS入院的患者(85例[43%]为女性,114例[57%]为男性),实施后有119例(62例[52%]为女性,57例[48%]为男性)。非土著队列中,在护理模式实施前有440例ACS患者(140例[32%]为女性,300例[68%]为男性),实施后有467例(143例[31%]为女性,324例[69%]为男性)。与实施前组相比,实施后入院的土著患者的主要结局有显著降低(199例中的67例[34%] vs 119例中的24例[20%];风险比0.60,95%置信区间0.40 - 0.90;p = 0.012),这是由非计划心脏再入院的减少所驱动的(199例中的64例[32%] vs 119例中的21例[18%];0.55,0.35 - 0.85;p = 0.0060)。在90天的综合终点方面,非土著患者在实施前和实施后的时间段之间没有显著变化(440例中的81例[18%] vs 467例中的93例[20%];1.08,0.83 - 1.41;p = 0.54)。实施前,土著患者的主要结局发生率显著高于非土著患者(p < 0.0001),在实施后阶段没有显著差异(p = 0.92)。
在澳大利亚一家三级医院,为土著患者实施具有文化针对性的护理模式后,其临床治疗结果得到改善,实施前存在的土著和非土著患者之间主要终点发生率的差异有所减小。
昆士兰卫生部原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民健康司(现为第一民族健康办公室)。