Webster D
Nurs Res. 1985 Sep-Oct;34(5):313-7.
Problems of interprofessional relationships in the health care field were examined by asking medical students what experiences were important to the development of their views of nurses and nursing. First, field observations were made in nine hospitals affiliated with a large medical school. They were followed by individual tape-recorded, semi-structured interviews with 60 medical students randomly selected and stratified on the basis of year in the program and sex of the student. Ten males and five females from each of the 4 years comprised the sample. Analytic induction was used for data analysis and incorporated cross-classification within topical categories to quantitatively determine trends. Findings revealed that while students' views of the health care team tended to be general and broadly inclusive among first- and second-year students, fourth-year students more often described specific personnel who could contribute directly to a particular patients' treatment as defined by the patient's medical diagnosis. Over the 4 years of medical school, students' perception of the physician's role vis-à-vis the patient and the health care team became more specific, while their perception of the nurse's role became more vague and diffuse. Factors contributing to confusion between the roles of the medical student and the nurse are identified and discussed.
通过询问医学生哪些经历对他们形成对护士及护理工作的看法至关重要,来研究医疗保健领域跨专业关系的问题。首先,对一所大型医学院附属的九家医院进行了实地观察。随后,对60名医学生进行了单独的录音半结构化访谈,这些学生是根据在课程中的年级和性别随机挑选并分层的。样本包括每个年级的10名男性和5名女性。数据分析采用分析归纳法,并在主题类别内进行交叉分类以定量确定趋势。研究结果显示,虽然一、二年级学生对医疗团队的看法往往较为笼统且具有广泛包容性,但四年级学生更常描述那些能够根据患者的医学诊断直接为特定患者治疗做出贡献的具体人员。在医学院的四年里,学生对医生相对于患者和医疗团队角色的认知变得更加具体,而他们对护士角色的认知则变得更加模糊和宽泛。文中还识别并讨论了导致医学生和护士角色混淆的因素。