INSERM U955, Translational Neuropsychiatry Team, Institut Mondor de La Recherche Biomédicale (IRMB), University of Paris Est Créteil, Paris, France.
IFMK, Valentin Haüy Vocational Training and Rehabilitation Center, Paris, France.
Anat Sci Educ. 2024 Jun;17(4):779-795. doi: 10.1002/ase.2404. Epub 2024 Mar 23.
While traditional anatomy education often emphasizes passive learning and rote memorization, it seldom employs constructivist theories that focus on active, hands-on experiences for effective learning. This study tests the hypothesis that tactile experiences with modeling clay enhance geometric mental representation more effectively than verbal descriptions. We examine the potential of clay modeling to reflect and evaluate students' mental representation of anatomical structures. Utilizing a prospective randomized, open, blind endpoint (PROBE) design, we engaged 36 participants divided into three groups: blind, visually impaired, and a control group. The primary outcome measure was the difference between post-touch score and pre-touch score, which gauged the efficacy of tactile intervention in enhancing the participants' capacity to mentally reconstruct a well-designed anatomical fiction structure. Scoring was executed using a double-blind double-evaluation methodology, positioning clay model reconstruction as both an objective reliable assessment and a pedagogical tool. The analysis demonstrated a pronounced improvement in mental representation of anatomical structures, particularly in spatial comprehension and detailed textural discernment, with the mean score soaring from 47.81 pre-touch to 85.09 post-touch. Distinct cognitive processing adaptations were evident across groups, with the blind group excelling in tactile acuity and the visually impaired group showing the most significant gains in spatial understanding post-intervention (Cohen's d = 2.74). The application of modeling clay as a tactile intervention tool can significantly improve the learning of anatomy among medical students. The study underscores the value of active, multisensory engagement and customized teaching strategies for effective anatomy education among this demographic.
虽然传统的解剖学教育通常强调被动学习和死记硬背,但它很少采用建构主义理论,而建构主义理论侧重于主动的、实践的经验,以实现有效的学习。本研究检验了这样一个假设,即使用模型黏土进行触觉体验能比口头描述更有效地增强几何心理表象。我们研究了黏土模型在反映和评估学生对解剖结构的心理表象方面的潜力。本研究采用前瞻性随机、开放、盲终点(PROBE)设计,共纳入 36 名参与者,分为三组:盲组、视障组和对照组。主要结局指标是触摸后评分与触摸前评分之间的差异,该差异衡量了触觉干预增强参与者心理重建精心设计的虚构解剖结构的能力的效果。评分采用双盲双评估方法进行,将黏土模型重建作为客观可靠的评估和教学工具。分析表明,解剖结构的心理表象得到了明显改善,特别是在空间理解和详细纹理辨别方面,触摸前平均得分为 47.81,触摸后平均得分为 85.09。不同组之间存在明显的认知处理适应,盲组在触觉敏锐度方面表现出色,视障组在干预后空间理解方面的获益最大(Cohen's d = 2.74)。将模型黏土作为触觉干预工具的应用可以显著提高医学生对解剖学的学习效果。该研究强调了在这个人群中进行有效的解剖学教育时,积极的、多感官的参与和定制化教学策略的重要性。