Al Modanat Zaid, Al-Husinat Lou'i, Mistarihi Bashar M, Tashtoush Mohammad, Alsarabi Jood, Matalqah Rama, Mistarihi Hassan, Amir Mohammad Wasfi, Debajah Nawal, Rejoub Esra'a, Bereshy Raneem, Tawaha Mustafa, Talj Rana, Varrassi Giustino
Department of Clinical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, Yarmouk University, Irbid, JOR.
Department of Clinical Medical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, Yarmouk University, Irbid, JOR.
Cureus. 2024 Feb 23;16(2):e54746. doi: 10.7759/cureus.54746. eCollection 2024 Feb.
Background In the realm of surgical procedures, patients and anesthesiologists have distinct concerns that can have an impact on their relationship. Patients are often riddled with anxiety about the unknowns of anesthesia and the possible risks. Anesthesiologists, too, face their own set of concerns. Despite the importance of this interaction, there has been little research on the specific concerns of both parties. Our study aims to fill this gap by describing and comparing the concerns of patients and anesthesiologists in Jordan. Methodology This cross-sectional study evaluated anesthesia-related problems based on specific questionnaires. The responses to the questionnaires were on a voluntary basis. The consent of the participants was granted after the aims of the study were clarified. Data were collected and analyzed using SPSS version 28 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Results A total of 155 Jordanian anesthesiologists and 1,858 participants from the population who had undergone anesthesia participated in the study. In general anesthesia, over 60% of the anesthesiologists were most worried about ventilation and intubation difficulties during anesthesia induction and death at the end of anesthesia. Regarding regional anesthesia, the primary concerns included toxicity from local anesthesia infiltration (64.5%) and total spinal anesthesia (49.0%). Patients were concerned about various anesthesia-related scenarios, with the highest worries about pain (3.41/4), a sharp drop in vital signs (3.40/4), and an irregular heartbeat (3.39/4). Female patients, those with lower incomes, and those with a bachelor's degree reported higher anesthesia concern levels. Additionally, anesthesiologists' mean concern score was significantly lower than that of patients. Conclusions Patients concentrated on pain, a drop in vital signs, and irregular heartbeats, whereas anesthesiologists were worried about ventilation, intubation, and hypoxia. Patients placed more emphasis on personal experiences and social factors than technical issues. Therefore, patient education about anesthesia and discussion about intra and postoperative expectations are imperative to improve the surgical experience and the relationship between patients and anesthesiologists.
背景 在外科手术领域,患者和麻醉医生有着不同的担忧,这些担忧可能会影响他们之间的关系。患者常常对麻醉的未知因素和潜在风险充满焦虑。麻醉医生也面临着他们自己的一系列担忧。尽管这种互动很重要,但针对双方具体担忧的研究却很少。我们的研究旨在通过描述和比较约旦患者和麻醉医生的担忧来填补这一空白。
方法 这项横断面研究基于特定问卷评估与麻醉相关的问题。问卷回复是自愿的。在阐明研究目的后,获得了参与者的同意。使用SPSS 28版(美国纽约州阿蒙克市IBM公司)收集和分析数据。
结果 共有155名约旦麻醉医生和1858名接受过麻醉的人群参与者参与了该研究。在全身麻醉中,超过60%的麻醉医生最担心麻醉诱导期间的通气和插管困难以及麻醉结束时的死亡。对于区域麻醉,主要担忧包括局部麻醉药浸润毒性(64.5%)和全脊髓麻醉(49.0%)。患者担心各种与麻醉相关的情况,最担心的是疼痛(3.41/4)、生命体征急剧下降(3.40/4)和心跳不规则(3.39/4)。女性患者、低收入患者和拥有学士学位的患者报告的麻醉担忧程度较高。此外,麻醉医生的平均担忧得分显著低于患者。
结论 患者关注疼痛、生命体征下降和心跳不规则,而麻醉医生担心通气、插管和缺氧。患者更强调个人经历和社会因素而非技术问题。因此,对患者进行麻醉教育并讨论术中及术后期望对于改善手术体验以及患者与麻醉医生之间的关系至关重要。