Schor Nina F
National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke.
J Women Educ Leadersh. 2021;2021. doi: 10.32873/unl.dc.jwel.198. Epub 2021 Jan 26.
The present studies compare, between Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs; n=102) and a non-HBCU cohort matched for location, religious and vocational mission, and student enrollment (comparator CUs; n=102), the programmatic foci of women in institutional leadership positions. They demonstrate that, at HBCUs, women are more prevalent in leadership roles with male-dominated foci (e.g., finance), and less prevalent in roles with female-dominated foci (e.g., public relations) than at comparator CUs (p < 0.01). A survey of academic leaders (n=1,053 invited; 111 viewed survey; 83 completed survey) at these institutions indicates that women leaders at HBCUs more frequently fill institutional programmatic gaps than their counterparts at comparator CUs (p < 0.001) or men in any academic setting (p < 0.005). Reasons may include the social purpose of HBCUs; the stereotype threat of the traditional "service" role of women and the unique intersectionality encountered by Black women faculty; and the importance of race over gender in homosociability at HBCUs. This suggests that emphasis on the socioeconomic mission and philosophy of higher education may enhance faculty recruitment diversification efforts in higher education. It also raises the question of whether seeing women in atypical leadership roles influences the career aspirations and attitudes towards women leaders of the students, both men and women, at HBCUs.
本研究比较了历史上的黑人学院和大学(HBCUs;n = 102)与在地理位置、宗教和职业使命以及学生入学人数方面相匹配的非HBCU同类院校(比较组CU;n = 102)中担任机构领导职务的女性的项目重点。研究表明,在HBCUs,与比较组CU相比,女性在以男性为主导的重点领域(如金融)担任领导角色的情况更为普遍,而在以女性为主导的重点领域(如公共关系)担任领导角色的情况则较少(p < 0.01)。对这些机构的学术领导者(n = 1053人受邀;111人查看了调查;83人完成了调查)进行的一项调查表明,HBCUs的女性领导者比比较组CU的同行(p < 0.001)或任何学术环境中的男性(p < 0.005)更频繁地填补机构项目空白。原因可能包括HBCUs的社会目的;女性传统“服务”角色的刻板印象威胁以及黑人女性教师所面临的独特交叉性;以及在HBCUs的同质性中种族比性别更重要。这表明,强调高等教育的社会经济使命和理念可能会加强高等教育中教师招聘的多元化努力。这也提出了一个问题,即看到女性担任非典型领导角色是否会影响HBCUs的男女学生对女性领导者的职业抱负和态度。