Tariq Shazia, Singh Nilanjana
Obstetrics and Gynecology, Kanad Hospital, Abu Dhabi, ARE.
Cureus. 2024 Feb 25;16(2):e54880. doi: 10.7759/cureus.54880. eCollection 2024 Feb.
This study explores the success rates and cultural influences on the decision-making process for vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) in the United Arab Emirates (UAE).
An observational cohort study was conducted at a hospital in the UAE accredited by Joint Commission International, enrolling 263 women eligible for VBAC from March 1, 2018, to February 28, 2019. The study focused on maternal-fetal outcomes, the proportions of women opting for trial of labor after cesarean (TOLAC) versus elective repeat cesarean section (ERCS), and the impact of cultural backgrounds on these decisions.
The study found significant cultural variations in VBAC acceptance and success rates. Among local Emirati/Omani women, 86% (152 out of 177) opted for TOLAC, with an 83% success rate (126 out of 152). In contrast, lower TOLAC uptake and success rates were observed among other nationalities, such as Egyptian and other Arab women. The study also noted higher VBAC success rates in women with prior vaginal deliveries and those who experienced spontaneous labor. NICU admissions and maternal readmissions were lower in the TOLAC group (1% NICU admissions and 2% maternal readmissions) compared to the ERCS group (8.2% NICU admissions).
The study underscores the influence of cultural factors in VBAC decision-making and outcomes, highlighting the need for culturally tailored counseling and care. It also confirms the safety and efficacy of VBAC in appropriately selected cases, advocating for more research into counseling practices and long-term outcomes in culturally diverse populations. Impact statement: This research adds to the understanding of how cultural and ethnic backgrounds influence VBAC decisions and outcomes, offering critical insights for clinical practice, especially in multicultural societies like the UAE. It emphasizes the role of tailored counseling and suggests avenues for future research in this domain.
本研究探讨阿拉伯联合酋长国(阿联酋)剖宫产术后阴道分娩(VBAC)的成功率以及文化对其决策过程的影响。
在一家获得国际联合委员会认证的阿联酋医院进行了一项观察性队列研究,纳入了2018年3月1日至2019年2月28日期间符合VBAC条件的263名女性。该研究聚焦于母婴结局、剖宫产术后试产(TOLAC)与择期再次剖宫产(ERCS)的女性比例,以及文化背景对这些决策的影响。
研究发现VBAC接受率和成功率存在显著的文化差异。在当地阿联酋/阿曼女性中,86%(177名中的152名)选择了TOLAC,成功率为83%(152名中的126名)。相比之下,埃及和其他阿拉伯等其他国籍女性的TOLAC接受率和成功率较低。研究还指出,既往有阴道分娩史和经历过自然分娩的女性VBAC成功率较高。与ERCS组(8.2%的新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)收治率)相比,TOLAC组的NICU收治率(1%)和产妇再次入院率(2%)较低。
该研究强调了文化因素对VBAC决策和结局的影响,突出了进行文化针对性咨询和护理的必要性。它还证实了在适当选择的病例中VBAC的安全性和有效性,倡导对文化多元人群的咨询实践和长期结局进行更多研究。影响声明:本研究增进了对文化和种族背景如何影响VBAC决策和结局的理解,为临床实践提供了重要见解,尤其是在像阿联酋这样的多元文化社会。它强调了针对性咨询的作用,并为该领域未来的研究指明了方向。