Ms Willis is affiliated with Respiratory Care Services, Arkansas Children's Hospital, Little Rock, Arkansas.
Respir Care. 2024 Mar 27;69(4):492-499. doi: 10.4187/respcare.11838.
The purpose of peer review is to evaluate the scientific merit of the submitted work and to assess suitability for publication. This process is intended to provide an unbiased, independent critique to ensure publication of high-quality manuscripts that demonstrate validity and reliability. Reviewers are subject-matter experts who volunteer their time to participate in peer review. A proper review provides constructive and helpful feedback in a timely manner that authors can use to improve both current and future work. When given the opportunity to revise, authors should carefully consider all comments and adequately address all concerns. This paper provides guidance to clinicians for both aspects of the peer review process: participating as a reviewer and responding to reviewer feedback.
同行评审的目的是评估提交作品的科学价值，并评估其适合发表的程度。该过程旨在提供公正、独立的评估，以确保发表具有有效性和可靠性的高质量稿件。评审员是自愿参与同行评审的主题专家。适当的评审会及时提供建设性和有益的反馈，作者可以利用这些反馈来改进当前和未来的工作。有机会修改时，作者应仔细考虑所有意见，并充分解决所有问题。本文为临床医生提供了同行评审过程的两个方面的指导：作为评审员参与和回复评审员的反馈。
