Gómez-Méndez Irving, Amornbunchornvej Chainarong
National Electronics and Computer Technology Center (NECTEC), Thailand.
Heliyon. 2024 Mar 15;10(6):e27968. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e27968. eCollection 2024 Mar 30.
One-shirt-size policy cannot handle poverty issues well since each area has its unique challenges, while having a custom-made policy for each area separately is unrealistic due to limitation of resources as well as having issues of ignoring dependencies of characteristics between different areas. In this work, we propose to use Bayesian hierarchical models which can potentially explain the data regarding income and other poverty-related variables in the multi-resolution governing structural data of Thailand. We discuss the journey of how we design each model from simple to more complex ones, estimate their performance in terms of variable explanation and complexity, discuss models' drawbacks, as well as propose the solutions to fix issues in the lens of Bayesian hierarchical models in order to get insight from data. We found that Bayesian hierarchical models performed better than both complete pooling (single policy) and no pooling models (custom-made policy). Additionally, by adding the year-of-education variable, the hierarchical model enriches its performance of variable explanation. We found that having a higher education level increases significantly the households' income for all the regions in Thailand. The impact of the region in the households' income is almost vanished when education level or years of education are considered. Therefore, education might have a mediation role between regions and the income. Our work can serve as a guideline for other countries that require the Bayesian hierarchical approach to model their variables and get insight from data.
一刀切的政策无法很好地应对贫困问题,因为每个地区都有其独特的挑战,而由于资源限制以及忽视不同地区特征之间的依存关系等问题,为每个地区单独制定定制政策是不现实的。在这项工作中,我们建议使用贝叶斯分层模型,该模型有可能解释泰国多分辨率治理结构数据中有关收入及其他与贫困相关变量的数据。我们讨论了如何从简单模型到更复杂模型设计每个模型的过程,评估它们在变量解释和复杂性方面的性能,讨论模型的缺点,并从贝叶斯分层模型的角度提出解决问题的方案,以便从数据中获得见解。我们发现,贝叶斯分层模型的表现优于完全合并(单一政策)模型和不合并模型(定制政策)。此外,通过添加受教育年限变量,分层模型增强了其变量解释性能。我们发现,在泰国所有地区,受教育程度较高会显著增加家庭收入。当考虑教育水平或受教育年限时,地区对家庭收入的影响几乎消失。因此,教育可能在地区和收入之间起到中介作用。我们的工作可以为其他需要采用贝叶斯方法对变量进行建模并从数据中获得见解的国家提供指导。