Temple University, United States of America.
Temple University, United States of America.
J Subst Use Addict Treat. 2024 Jul;162:209358. doi: 10.1016/j.josat.2024.209358. Epub 2024 Mar 27.
Compared to the general U.S. adolescent population, young people involved in the juvenile justice system are at greater risk of experiencing substance use (SU) issues. There are critical opportunities across the juvenile justice continuum, at points of interface with community-based treatment services, to screen and assess for SU issues, identify unmet treatment needs, and refer those in need to treatment. The treatment referral process is, however, complex, and contingent on a seamless nexus between juvenile justice operations and the wider treatment provider landscape. Given the lack of successful SU referrals among justice-involved youth and the variable referral rates across jurisdictions, this study's aim is to provide a qualitative, explanatory understanding of the conditions that together contribute to successful referring practices.
The study is based on an analysis of a qualitative dataset comprising focus group data with probation and community-based behavioral health treatment staff working in 31 sites in 6 different states as part of the clustered randomized trial of an organizational change intervention known as JJ-TRIALS (Juvenile Justice Translational Research on Interventions for Adolescents in the Legal System). The data contain respondents' narratives on the achievements, successes, and challenges with implementing the intervention. The data were analyzed through a combination of strategies to identify the conditions that both facilitate and impede referral processes between probation offices and community-based SU treatment providers.
Participants across sites discussed the positive impacts that the JJ-TRIALS intervention had on their improved ability to communicate, collaborate, and collect data. From the interviews, seven main conditions were observed to contribute to successful SU treatment referral practices: (1) communication (inter-organizational); (2) collaboration; (3) data-driven practices; (4) family engagement; (5) institutionalized policy and referral documentation; (6) efficient referral policies and procedures; and (7) suitable and accessible system of treatment providers.
Findings highlight the value of a holistic understanding of successful treatment referrals for justice-involved youth and help inform research and practice efforts to identify and measure the many dimensions of referral-making at the interface of juvenile probation and behavioral health services.
与普通美国青少年群体相比,参与少年司法系统的年轻人更有可能出现物质使用(SU)问题。在少年司法系统的各个环节,尤其是在与社区为基础的治疗服务相衔接的地方,都有重要的机会对 SU 问题进行筛查和评估,确定未满足的治疗需求,并将有需要的人转介到治疗机构。然而,治疗转介过程非常复杂,取决于少年司法运作与更广泛的治疗服务提供者之间的无缝联系。鉴于有犯罪记录的青少年的成功转介率较低,而且各司法管辖区的转介率也各不相同,本研究旨在从定性角度深入了解促成成功转介实践的条件。
本研究基于对定性数据集的分析,该数据集由 31 个地点的 6 个不同州的缓刑和社区为基础的行为健康治疗工作人员的焦点小组数据组成,作为一个名为 JJ-TRIALS(青少年司法系统中干预措施的转化研究)的组织变革干预措施的聚类随机试验的一部分。这些数据包含了受访者关于实施干预措施的成就、成功和挑战的叙述。通过一系列策略对数据进行分析,以确定促进和阻碍缓刑办公室和社区为基础的 SU 治疗提供者之间转介过程的条件。
各地点的参与者都讨论了 JJ-TRIALS 干预措施对他们改善沟通、协作和数据收集能力的积极影响。从访谈中观察到,有七个主要条件有助于成功的 SU 治疗转介实践:(1)跨组织沟通;(2)合作;(3)数据驱动的实践;(4)家庭参与;(5)制度化的政策和转介文件;(6)高效的转介政策和程序;以及(7)合适且可及的治疗提供者系统。
研究结果强调了全面了解有犯罪记录的青少年成功治疗转介的价值,并有助于为识别和衡量少年缓刑和行为健康服务接口处的转介决策的许多维度提供研究和实践依据。