Department of Health Sciences, Brunel University London, Uxbridge, UK.
School of Health Sciences, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Chron Respir Dis. 2024 Jan-Dec;21:14799731241238435. doi: 10.1177/14799731241238435.
This study aimed to determine the feasibility of a group-based pilot programme of low-to-moderate physical activity training, education and social activities, by investigating acceptability, practicality, implementation and efficacy testing. We offer suggestions on programme adaptions for future study.
People with a range of chronic respiratory diseases were invited to participate in a pilot 12 week group activity programme. Activities included outdoor walking, tai-chi, education and a range of social activities. Acceptability was determined by participant experiences determined during interviews. Practicality was determined by programme and outcome measure completion, cost and adverse events. Implementation was determined according to whether the programme ran as planned. Efficacy was determined by statistical analyses of outcomes including hand grip strength, timed up and go test, COPD Helplessness Index, COPD Assessment Test, and measures of physical activity via accelerometry.
Thematic analysis indicated that the "BreatheHappy" programme was acceptable. Seven of nine participants completed eight out of 10 sessions and the majority completed all outcome measures. "BreatheHappy" was therefore considered practical. The programme was not implemented as planned, with only 10 sessions running rather than the 12 intended. There was a significant increase in daily step counts (MD: 1284 95% CI: 240-2329 : 0.024 effect size: 0.988), stepping time (MD: 16 min 95% CI: 5-27 min : 0.011 effect size: 1.36) and daily minutes completing light physical activity (MD: 23 95% CI: 6-38 : 0.006 effect size: 1.6). However, time spent sitting for ≥30 min but ≤60 min significantly increased (MD: 26 95% CI: 0.2-52 min : 0.049 effect size: 0.931), showing signs of efficacy and changing physical activity behaviour patterns.
A 10-week programme of low-moderate physical activity training, education and social activities shows signs of feasibility for future research. Suggested adaptions for future study include using physical activity measures such as daily step count or light physical activity for a primary outcome, and mental health and social health related outcome measures relatable to participant's beneficial experiences of the programme. Recruitment in future studies will try and reach both those less socially active and possibly those who have completed pulmonary rehabilitation (PR). Venues should be close to efficient transport links whilst different frequencies and durations of programme delivery should be trialled. Adequate funding should be provided for both staff running the programme and blinded research staff for outcome measurement.
本研究旨在通过调查可接受性、实用性、实施情况和疗效测试,确定基于小组的低到中度体力活动训练、教育和社交活动方案的可行性。我们为未来的研究提供了方案调整的建议。
邀请患有各种慢性呼吸系统疾病的人参加为期 12 周的小组活动方案。活动包括户外散步、太极拳、教育和各种社交活动。可接受性是通过参与者在访谈中确定的经验来确定的。实用性是通过方案和结果测量的完成情况、成本和不良事件来确定的。实施情况是根据方案是否按计划进行来确定的。疗效是通过对握力、计时起立行走测试、COPD 无助感指数、COPD 评估测试以及通过加速度计测量的体力活动等结果的统计分析来确定的。
主题分析表明,“BreatheHappy”方案是可以接受的。9 名参与者中有 7 人完成了 10 个疗程中的 8 个,大多数人完成了所有的结果测量。因此,“BreatheHappy”被认为是实用的。该方案没有按计划实施,只进行了 10 个疗程,而不是计划的 12 个疗程。每日步数(MD:1284 95%CI:240-2329 :0.024 效应量:0.988)、踏步时间(MD:16 分钟 95%CI:5-27 分钟:0.011 效应量:1.36)和每日完成轻度体力活动的时间(MD:23 95%CI:6-38 :0.006 效应量:1.6)均显著增加。然而,每天坐着超过 30 分钟但不超过 60 分钟的时间显著增加(MD:26 95%CI:0.2-52 分钟:0.049 效应量:0.931),表明该方案具有疗效,并改变了参与者的体力活动行为模式。
一项为期 10 周的低到中度体力活动训练、教育和社交活动方案显示出未来研究的可行性迹象。未来研究的建议调整包括使用日常步数或轻度体力活动等体力活动测量作为主要结果,以及与参与者从方案中受益相关的心理健康和社会健康相关结果测量。未来的研究将尝试招募那些社交活动较少的人,以及那些可能已经完成肺康复(PR)的人。场地应靠近高效的交通连接,同时应尝试不同的方案交付频率和持续时间。应提供足够的资金,用于方案运行人员和进行结果测量的盲法研究人员。