Eriksson L, Westesson P L
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1985 Apr;43(4):263-9. doi: 10.1016/0278-2391(85)90284-8.
Meniscectomy for treatment of pain and dysfunction of the temporomandibular joint is a controversial operation because of the possible late complications of limitation of movement and pain. Therefore, the long-term results of this operation were clinically and radiologically investigated in a sample of 15 patients that had had meniscectomies performed during the period from 1947-1960 (mean follow up, 29 years). On clinical examination, all patients were free of pain, none had subjectively experienced dysfunction, and all but one could open their mouths more than 39 mm. Two thirds of the operated joints were crepitant. Radiologically all joints showed structural hard-tissue changes, mainly the presence of osteophytes and flattening of the condyle and tubercle. Absence of joint space was seen in half of the joints. The results indicate that meniscectomy relieves joint pain and eliminates subjectively perceived dysfunction in the long term despite the presence of clinical and radiologic signs of degenerative joint disease; however, as the condition of many patients who have temporomandibular joint disorders improves over time without surgery, there is a need for a controlled study on the value of meniscectomy.
由于可能存在运动受限和疼痛等晚期并发症,颞下颌关节半月板切除术用于治疗颞下颌关节疼痛和功能障碍是一种存在争议的手术。因此,对1947年至1960年期间接受半月板切除术的15例患者样本进行了该手术长期效果的临床和放射学研究(平均随访29年)。临床检查发现,所有患者均无疼痛,无一例主观上有功能障碍体验,除一人外,所有人张口度均超过39毫米。三分之二的手术关节有摩擦音。放射学检查显示,所有关节均有结构上的硬组织改变,主要表现为骨赘形成以及髁突和结节变平。半数关节可见关节间隙消失。结果表明,尽管存在退行性关节病的临床和放射学征象,但半月板切除术长期来看可缓解关节疼痛并消除主观感觉到的功能障碍;然而,由于许多颞下颌关节紊乱患者的病情随时间推移即使未经手术也会改善,因此有必要对半月板切除术的价值进行对照研究。