Prashanth K B, Mathew Riya Ann, Manjunatha H A, Puneeth P J
Department Of Otorhinolaryngology, JJM Medical College, Davangere, Karnataka India.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2024 Apr;76(2):1522-1525. doi: 10.1007/s12070-023-04351-7. Epub 2023 Nov 27.
Benign laryngeal lesions like vocal nodules, vocal polyp, vocal fold cysts are mostly found in patients complaining of change in voice. S/Z ratio has become the most frequently used clinical tool to assess phonatory mechanics. This study shows the pre-treatment and post-treatment comparison of S/Z ratios in patients with benign laryngeal lesions. To evaluate the outcome of microlaryngeal surgery in patients with benign laryngeal lesions using S/Z ratio as an outcome parameter. During this study, 65 patients with complaints of change in voice, with clinical evidence of benign laryngeal lesions underwent microlaryngeal surgery. Improvement in symptoms were measured preoperatively and postoperatively using S/Z ratio. This ratio was calculated by asking the patient to to maximally sustain 'S' and 'Z', repeated thrice. S/Z ratio was calculated by dividing the maximum duration for which /S/ was sustained by the maximum duration for which /Z/ was sustained. A ratio of more than 1.4 suggested a vocal cord disorder. There was statistically significant difference observed in S/Z ratio values, from pre-treatment to 6 months post-treatment, with value 0.001. Pre and post treatment assessment of patients with benign vocal fold lesions showed significant improvement in S/Z ratio postoperatively. It is the simplest and a reliable objective method of voice assessment and can also be used in assessing the outcome of the treatment.
声带小结、声带息肉、声带囊肿等良性喉部病变多见于主诉声音改变的患者。S/Z比值已成为评估发声机制最常用的临床工具。本研究展示了良性喉部病变患者治疗前后S/Z比值的对比情况。以S/Z比值作为结果参数,评估显微喉镜手术治疗良性喉部病变患者的疗效。在本研究中,65例主诉声音改变且有良性喉部病变临床证据的患者接受了显微喉镜手术。术前和术后使用S/Z比值来衡量症状改善情况。该比值通过让患者最大限度地持续发“S”和“Z”音,重复三次来计算。S/Z比值通过将发/S/音的最长持续时间除以发/Z/音的最长持续时间得出。比值大于1.4提示声带功能障碍。从治疗前到治疗后6个月,S/Z比值的数值存在统计学显著差异,P值为0.001。对良性声带病变患者的治疗前和治疗后评估显示,术后S/Z比值有显著改善。它是一种简单且可靠的客观嗓音评估方法,也可用于评估治疗效果。