Assistant Professor, Department of Emergency Medicine, Indiana University School of Medicine.
Associate Professor, Department of Emergency Medicine, Indiana University School of Medicine.
MedEdPORTAL. 2024 Apr 2;20:11394. doi: 10.15766/mep_2374-8265.11394. eCollection 2024.
Medical errors are an unfortunate certainty with emotional and psychological consequences for patients and health care providers. No standardized medical curriculum on how to disclose medical errors to patients or peers exists. The novel HEEAL (honesty/empathy/education/apology-awareness/lessen chance for future errors) curriculum addresses this gap in medical education through a multimodality workshop.
This 6-hour, two-part curriculum incorporated didactic and standardized patient (SP) simulation education with rapid cycle deliberate practice (RCDP). The morning focused on provider-patient error disclosure; the afternoon applied the same principles to provider-provider (peer) discussion. Summative simulations with SPs evaluated learners' skill baseline and improvement. Formative simulations run by expert simulation educators used RCDP to provide real-time feedback and opportunities for adjustment. Medical knowledge was measured through pre- and postintervention multiple-choice questions. Learners' confidence and attitude towards medical errors disclosure were surveyed pre- and postintervention with assistance of the Barriers to Error Disclosure Assessment tool, revised with the addition of several questions related to provider-provider disclosure.
Fourteen medical students participated in this pilot curriculum. Statistical significance was demonstrated in medical knowledge ( = .01), peer-disclosure skills ( = .001), and confidence in medical error disclosure ( < .001). Although there was improvement in patient-disclosure skills, this did not reach statistical significance ( = .05).
This curriculum addresses the need for designated training in medical error disclosure. Learners gained knowledge, skills, and confidence in medical error disclosure. We recommend this curriculum for medical students preparing for transition to residency.
医疗失误是不可避免的,会给患者和医疗保健提供者带来情感和心理上的后果。目前还没有关于如何向患者或同行披露医疗失误的标准化医学课程。新型 HEEAL(诚实/同理心/教育/道歉意识/减少未来错误的机会)课程通过多模式研讨会弥补了医学教育中的这一空白。
这个 6 小时的两部分课程结合了讲座和标准化患者(SP)模拟教育以及快速循环刻意练习(RCDP)。上午的课程重点是医患之间的失误披露;下午则将同样的原则应用于医患(同行)讨论。SP 进行的总结性模拟评估了学习者的技能基础和改进情况。由专家模拟教育者进行的形成性模拟使用 RCDP 提供实时反馈和调整机会。通过干预前后的多项选择题来衡量医学知识。在错误披露评估工具的帮助下,对学习者在干预前后的信心和对医疗失误披露的态度进行了调查,该工具经过修订,增加了几个与医患披露相关的问题。
14 名医学生参加了这个试点课程。医学知识(p =.01)、同行披露技能(p =.001)和对医疗失误披露的信心(p <.001)都有显著提高。尽管患者披露技能有所提高,但这并未达到统计学意义(p =.05)。
该课程满足了医疗失误披露指定培训的需求。学习者在医疗失误披露方面获得了知识、技能和信心。我们建议将该课程推荐给即将进入住院医师实习期的医学生。