Kim Chan Woong, Myung Sun Jung, Eo Eun Kyung, Chang Yerim
Department of Emergency Medicine, Choong Ang University College of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Seoul National University College of Medicine, Office of Medical Education, 103 Daehak-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul, 110-799, Republic of Korea.
BMC Med Educ. 2017 Mar 4;17(1):52. doi: 10.1186/s12909-017-0880-9.
Although physicians believe that medical errors should be disclosed to patients and their families, they often hesitate to do so. In this study, we assessed the effectiveness of an education program for medical error disclosure.
In 2015, six medical interns and 79 fourth-year medical students participated in this study. The education program included practice of error disclosure using a standardized patient scenario, feedback, and short didactic sessions. Participant performance was evaluated with a previously developed rating scale that measures error disclosure performance on five specific component skills. Following education program, we surveyed participant perceptions of medical error disclosure with varying severity of error outcome and their satisfaction with the education program using a 5-point Likert scale. We also surveyed the change of attitude or confidence of participants after education program.
The performance score was not significantly different between medical interns and medical students (p = 0.840). Following the education program, 65% of participants said that they had become more confident in coping with medical errors, and most participants (79.7%) were satisfied with the education program. They also indicated that they felt a greater duty to disclose medical errors and deliver an apology when the medical error outcome is more severe.
An education program for disclosing medical errors was helpful in improving confidence in medical error disclosure. Extending the program to more diverse scenarios and a more diverse group of physicians is needed.
尽管医生认为应该向患者及其家属披露医疗差错,但他们往往对此犹豫不决。在本研究中,我们评估了一项关于医疗差错披露的教育项目的效果。
2015年,6名医学实习生和79名四年级医学生参与了本研究。该教育项目包括使用标准化患者场景进行差错披露练习、反馈以及简短的教学课程。使用先前制定的评分量表评估参与者的表现,该量表衡量在五项特定组成技能方面的差错披露表现。在教育项目结束后,我们使用5点李克特量表调查了参与者对不同差错结果严重程度的医疗差错披露的看法以及他们对该教育项目的满意度。我们还调查了教育项目后参与者态度或信心的变化。
医学实习生和医学生的表现得分无显著差异(p = 0.840)。在教育项目结束后,65%的参与者表示他们在应对医疗差错方面变得更有信心,并且大多数参与者(79.7%)对该教育项目感到满意。他们还表示,当医疗差错结果更严重时,他们感到有更大的责任披露医疗差错并道歉。
一项关于披露医疗差错的教育项目有助于提高对医疗差错披露的信心。需要将该项目扩展到更多样化的场景和更多样化的医生群体。