Camino-Willhuber Gaston, Tani Soji, Kelly Michael J, Schonnagel Lukas, Caffard Thomas, Chiapparelli Erika, Gorgy George, Dalton David, Zhu Jiaqi, Shue Jennifer, Zelenty William D, Cammisa Frank P, Girardi Federico P, Hughes Alexander P, Sama Andrew A, Sokunbi Gbolabo
Orthopaedic Surgery, Spine Care Institute, Hospital for Special Surgery, 535 E 70th St, New York, NY, United States.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, School of Medicine, Showa University Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
N Am Spine Soc J. 2024 Feb 23;18:100316. doi: 10.1016/j.xnsj.2024.100316. eCollection 2024 Jun.
The recommended timing for returning to common activities after cervical spine surgery varies widely among physicians based on training background and personal opinion, without clear guidelines or consensus. The purpose of this study was to analyze spine surgeons' responses about the recommended timing for returning to common activities after different cervical spine procedures.
This was a survey study including 91 spine surgeons. The participants were asked to complete an anonymous online survey. Questions regarding their recommended time for returning to regular activities (showering, driving, biking, running, swimming, sedentary work, and nonsedentary work) after anterior cervical decompression and fusion (ACDF), cervical disc replacement (CDR), posterior cervical decompression and fusion (PCDF), and laminoplasty were included. Comparisons of recommended times for return to activities after each surgical procedure were made based on surgeons' years in practice.
For ACDF and PCDF, there were no statistically significant differences in recommended times for return to any activity when stratified by years in practice. When considering CDR, return to non-sedentary work differed between surgeons in practice for 10 to 15 years, who recommended return at 3 months, and all other groups of surgeons, who recommended 6 weeks. Laminoplasty surgery yielded the most variability in activity recommendations, with earlier recommended return (6 weeks) to biking, non-sedentary work, and sedentary work in the most experienced surgeon group (>15 years in practice) than in all other surgeon experience groups (3 months).
We observed significant variability in surgeon recommendations for return to regular activities after cervical spine surgery.
颈椎手术后恢复日常活动的推荐时间,因医生的培训背景和个人观点不同而差异很大,目前尚无明确的指南或共识。本研究的目的是分析脊柱外科医生对于不同颈椎手术后恢复日常活动的推荐时间的回答。
这是一项包含91位脊柱外科医生的调查研究。参与者被要求完成一项匿名在线调查。问题包括他们对于颈椎前路减压融合术(ACDF)、颈椎间盘置换术(CDR)、颈椎后路减压融合术(PCDF)和椎板成形术后恢复日常活动(洗澡、开车、骑自行车、跑步、游泳、久坐工作和非久坐工作)的推荐时间。根据医生的从业年限,对每种手术后恢复活动的推荐时间进行比较。
对于ACDF和PCDF,按从业年限分层时,恢复任何活动的推荐时间在统计学上没有显著差异。考虑CDR时,从业10至15年的医生推荐术后3个月恢复非久坐工作,而其他所有医生组推荐6周恢复,二者存在差异。椎板成形术在活动推荐方面差异最大,经验最丰富的医生组(从业>15年)推荐比其他所有医生经验组更早(6周)恢复骑自行车、非久坐工作和久坐工作(其他组推荐3个月)。
我们观察到脊柱外科医生对于颈椎手术后恢复日常活动的推荐存在显著差异。