Schwienhorst-Stich Eva-Maria, Kropff Dana, Kersken Katharina, König Sarah, Leutritz Tobias, Parisi Sandra, Schlittenhardt Clara, Schmid Jörg, Simmenroth Anne, Jünger Jana, Zirkel Janina
Institut für Allgemeinmedizin, Universitätsklinikum Würzburg (UKW), Würzburg, Deutschland; Lehrklinik der Medizinischen Fakultät und Institut für Medizinische Lehre und Ausbildung, Universitätsklinikum Würzburg (UKW), Würzburg, Deutschland.
Institut für Allgemeinmedizin, Universitätsklinikum Würzburg (UKW), Würzburg, Deutschland.
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2024 May;186:92-103. doi: 10.1016/j.zefq.2023.12.001. Epub 2024 Apr 4.
The connections between climate, environment, and health as well as the concept of planetary health need to be integrated into the education of health professionals, as is increasingly demanded both internationally and nationally. Planetary health education should also aim to foster transformative action for climate protection and sustainability. In recent years, innovative teaching formats and objective catalogues have emerged internationally. In Germany, these topics have not yet been integrated into medical education everywhere. Since 2021, the Faculty of Medicine in Würzburg has offered an elective course as a first step of a longitudinal curriculum currently in development. The design, content, structure, and results of the evaluation are discussed in this article and will be used for quality assurance as well as the (further) development of this kind of educational interventions elsewhere.
We developed an elective course for students in their second to tenth semester with 30 onsite and online face-to-face teaching units and an additional project phase. We used an innovative mix of didactic methods with online simulations, training in climate-sensitive health counselling, and interdisciplinary climate communication as well as local sustainability projects in small groups, with a large amount of peer-teaching. A quantitative and qualitative evaluation was done immediately after the teaching units through feedback rounds and online with the evaluation software Evasys®, using closed and open-ended questions exploring learning progress (summer semester) and achievement of learning objectives (winter semester), motivation to participate, acceptance of teaching methods, attitudes, relevance, and further interest. The evaluation questionnaire was slightly modified for the winter semester.
In the summer and winter semester of 2021/2022, a total of 34 students (17 per semester) participated in the elective course; of these, 33 participated in the written evaluation. The evaluation in the summer semester (n = 17) showed a significant increase in self-assessed learning gain, the evaluation in the winter semester (n = 16) indicated a substantial achievement of learning objectives (mean = 3.96 of a 5-point Likert scale). Participants of both semesters (n = 33) regarded peer-teaching as a suitable method (mean = 4.2) and well-implemented (mean = 4.3). The topics were considered highly relevant but not adequately integrated into the main curriculum. There was a high level of interest in local impacts of climate and environmental changes and local measures for climate protection and sustainability. The specific projects in small groups may serve as examples of how transformative action can be promoted in education.
In the current dynamic development of the widely demanded integration of planetary health education into curricula, this elective course shows a possible and well-accepted example with a combination of various innovative didactic methods aiming at the levels of knowledge, attitudes, skills, and self-efficacy (or confidence) alike. The positive evaluation by the students and the high interest in local sustainability projects show the potential for future integration into the main curriculum.
The elective can serve as an inspiration to tackle the challenge of taking the steps from knowledge to action in planetary health education. While an elective cannot replace the integration of all relevant aspects of planetary health into the main curriculum, it can serve as a space for piloting of future curricular educational interventions and offer opportunities for developing transformative competencies.
气候、环境与健康之间的联系以及行星健康的概念需要纳入卫生专业人员的教育中,这在国际和国内的需求都日益增加。行星健康教育还应旨在促进气候保护和可持续发展的变革性行动。近年来,国际上出现了创新的教学形式和目标目录。在德国,这些主题尚未在各地的医学教育中得到整合。自2021年以来,维尔茨堡医学院开设了一门选修课,作为目前正在开发的纵向课程的第一步。本文讨论了该课程的设计、内容、结构和评估结果,并将用于质量保证以及其他地方此类教育干预措施的(进一步)开发。
我们为二至十学期的学生开发了一门选修课,包括30个现场和在线面对面教学单元以及一个额外的项目阶段。我们采用了创新的教学方法组合,包括在线模拟、气候敏感型健康咨询培训、跨学科气候交流以及小组中的地方可持续发展项目,并大量采用同伴教学。在教学单元结束后,通过反馈轮次并使用评估软件Evasys®在线进行定量和定性评估,使用封闭式和开放式问题探索学习进展(夏季学期)和学习目标的达成情况(冬季学期)、参与动机、对教学方法的接受程度、态度、相关性以及进一步的兴趣。评估问卷在冬季学期略有修改。
在2021/2022年夏季和冬季学期,共有34名学生(每学期17名)参加了这门选修课;其中33人参加了书面评估。夏季学期(n = 17)的评估显示自我评估的学习收获有显著增加,冬季学期(n = 16)的评估表明学习目标有实质性达成(5分李克特量表的平均分为3.96)。两个学期的参与者(n = 33)都认为同伴教学是一种合适的方法(平均分 = 4.2)且实施良好(平均分 = 4.3)。这些主题被认为高度相关,但未充分融入主课程。对气候和环境变化的地方影响以及地方气候保护和可持续发展措施有很高的兴趣。小组中的具体项目可作为在教育中促进变革性行动的示例。
在当前将行星健康教育广泛纳入课程的动态发展中,这门选修课展示了一个可能且广受接受的示例,它结合了各种创新教学方法,旨在提升知识、态度、技能和自我效能(或信心)水平。学生的积极评价以及对地方可持续发展项目的高度兴趣表明了未来融入主课程的潜力。
该选修课可作为应对行星健康教育中从知识到行动这一挑战的灵感来源。虽然一门选修课不能替代将行星健康的所有相关方面纳入主课程,但它可以作为未来课程教育干预措施的试点空间,并提供发展变革性能力的机会。