Liu Jinmeng, Wang Hui, Xing Shufen, Liu Xia
School of Psychological and Cognitive Sciences and Beijing Key Laboratory of Behavior and Mental Health, Peking University, Beijing, PR China.
Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Beijing University of Technology, Beijing, PR China.
Int J Clin Health Psychol. 2024 Apr-Jun;24(2):100456. doi: 10.1016/j.ijchp.2024.100456. Epub 2024 Mar 29.
Repetitive Nonsuicidal Self-Injury (R-NSSI) is complex and prevalent in adolescents. Although the reward system is a promising mechanism to explain R-NSSI, the specific processes of reward and punishment related to R-NSSI remain unclear. This study examined whether adolescents with R-NSSI displayed difficulties in both reward and punishment contexts, and further explored the role of inhibitory control in processing monetary reward and punishment.
Within a cohort from two middle schools ( = 3,475, 48.6 % female, = 12.95), a total of 187 adolescents completed three novel behavioral tasks. Specifically, in Study 1, 36 adolescents with R-NSSI and 28 without NSSI completed adapted incentive-delay tasks to evaluate sensitivity to reward and punishment. In Study 2, 27 adolescents with R-NSSI and 21 without NSSI were given novel incentive delay-two choice oddball task to evaluate the interaction between reward and inhibitory control. In Study 3, 38 adolescents with R-NSSI and 35 without NSSI completed similar task to assess the interaction between punishment and inhibitory control.
Adolescents with R-NSSI were characterized by higher levels of behavioral reward and punishment sensitivity than adolescents without NSSI. More importantly, the difference between reward and punishment in inhibitory control of R-NSSI was found. Compared to adolescents without NSSI, adolescents with R-NSSI showed lower levels of inhibitory control in response to cues depicting punishment content but not to those depicting reward content.
This study provides novel experimental evidence that heightened behavioral sensitivity to both reward and punishment may be relevant trait marker in R-NSSI among adolescents, and emphasizes that punishment not reward interact with inhibitory control in the R-NSSI.
重复性非自杀性自伤行为(R-NSSI)在青少年中很复杂且普遍存在。虽然奖赏系统是解释R-NSSI的一个有前景的机制,但与R-NSSI相关的奖赏和惩罚的具体过程仍不清楚。本研究调查了有R-NSSI的青少年在奖赏和惩罚情境中是否都存在困难,并进一步探讨了抑制控制在处理金钱奖赏和惩罚中的作用。
在来自两所中学的一个队列中(n = 3475,48.6%为女性,平均年龄 = 12.95岁),共有187名青少年完成了三项新颖的行为任务。具体而言,在研究1中,36名有R-NSSI的青少年和28名无NSSI的青少年完成了改编的激励延迟任务,以评估对奖赏和惩罚的敏感性。在研究2中,27名有R-NSSI的青少年和21名无NSSI的青少年接受了新颖的激励延迟二选一奇偶数任务,以评估奖赏与抑制控制之间的相互作用。在研究3中,38名有R-NSSI的青少年和35名无NSSI的青少年完成了类似任务,以评估惩罚与抑制控制之间的相互作用。
与无NSSI的青少年相比,有R-NSSI的青少年表现出更高水平的行为奖赏和惩罚敏感性。更重要的是,发现了R-NSSI在抑制控制方面奖赏与惩罚的差异。与无NSSI的青少年相比,有R-NSSI的青少年在对描绘惩罚内容的线索做出反应时表现出较低水平的抑制控制,但对描绘奖赏内容的线索则不然。
本研究提供了新的实验证据,表明对奖赏和惩罚的行为敏感性增强可能是青少年R-NSSI中的相关特质标记,并强调在R-NSSI中是惩罚而非奖赏与抑制控制相互作用。