Samanci Yavuz, Askeroglu M Orbay, Düzkalir Ali Haluk, Peker Selcuk
Department of Neurosurgery, Koc University School of Medicine, Istanbul, Turkey.
Gamma Knife Center, Department of Neurosurgery, Koc University Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey.
Brain Spine. 2024 Mar 20;4:102791. doi: 10.1016/j.bas.2024.102791. eCollection 2024.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a robust neuroimaging technique and is the preferred method for stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) planning. However, MRI data always contain distortions caused by hardware and patient factors.
Can these distortions potentially compromise the effectiveness and safety of SRS treatments?
Twenty-six MR datasets with multiple metastatic brain tumors (METs) used for Gamma Knife radiosurgery (GKRS) were retrospectively evaluated. A commercially available software was used for distortion correction. Geometrical agreement between corrected and uncorrected tumor volumes was evaluated using MacDonald criteria, Euclidian distance, and Dice similarity coefficient (DSC). SRS plans were generated using uncorrected tumor volumes, which were assessed to determine their coverage of the corrected tumor volumes.
The median target volume was 0.38 cm (range,0.01-12.38 cm3). A maximum displacement of METs of up to 2.87 mm and a median displacement of 0.55 mm (range,0.1-2.87 mm) were noted. The median DSC between uncorrected and corrected MRI was 0.92, and the most concerning case had a DSC of 0.46. Although all plans met the optimization criterion of at least 98% of the uncorrected tumor volume (median 99.55%, range 98.1-100%) receiving at least 100% of the prescription dose, the percent of the corrected tumor volume receiving the total prescription dose was a median of 95.45% (range,23.1-99.5%).
MRI distortion, though visually subtle, has significant implications for SRS planning. Regular utilization of corrected MRI is recommended for SRS planning as distortion is sometimes enough to cause a volumetric miss of SRS targets.
磁共振成像(MRI)是一种强大的神经成像技术,是立体定向放射外科手术(SRS)规划的首选方法。然而,MRI数据总是包含由硬件和患者因素引起的失真。
这些失真是否会潜在地损害SRS治疗的有效性和安全性?
回顾性评估了26个用于伽玛刀放射外科手术(GKRS)的患有多个脑转移瘤(METs)的MR数据集。使用市售软件进行失真校正。使用麦克唐纳标准、欧几里得距离和骰子相似系数(DSC)评估校正前后肿瘤体积的几何一致性。使用未校正的肿瘤体积生成SRS计划,并对其进行评估以确定它们对校正后肿瘤体积的覆盖情况。
目标体积中位数为0.38 cm³(范围为0.01 - 12.38 cm³)。观察到METs的最大位移达2.87 mm,中位位移为0.55 mm(范围为0.1 - 2.87 mm)。未校正和校正后的MRI之间的中位DSC为0.92,最严重的情况DSC为0.46。尽管所有计划均符合至少98%的未校正肿瘤体积(中位数为99.55%,范围为98.1 - 100%)接受至少100%处方剂量的优化标准,但接受总处方剂量的校正后肿瘤体积百分比中位数为95.45%(范围为23.1 - 99.5%)。
MRI失真虽然在视觉上不明显,但对SRS规划有重大影响。建议在SRS规划中常规使用校正后的MRI,因为失真有时足以导致SRS靶点的体积遗漏。