Institute for Cognitive and Brain Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.
Psychon Bull Rev. 2024 Oct;31(5):2058-2091. doi: 10.3758/s13423-024-02483-7. Epub 2024 Apr 8.
The investigation of cognitive processes that form the basis of decision-making in paradigms involving continuous outcomes has gained the interest of modeling researchers who aim to develop a dynamic decision theory that accounts for both speed and accuracy. One of the most important of these continuous models is the circular diffusion model (CDM, Smith. Psychological Review, 123(4), 425. 2016), which posits a noisy accumulation process mathematically described as a stochastic two-dimensional Wiener process inside a disk. Despite the considerable benefits of this model, its mathematical intricacy has limited its utilization among scholars. Here, we propose a straightforward and user-friendly method for estimating the CDM parameters and fitting the model to continuous-scale data using simple formulas that can be readily computed and do not require theoretical knowledge of model fitting or extensive programming. Notwithstanding its simplicity, we demonstrate that the aforementioned method performs with a level of accuracy that is comparable to that of the maximum likelihood estimation method. Furthermore, a robust version of the method is presented, which maintains its simplicity while exhibiting a high degree of resistance to contaminant responses. Additionally, we show that the approach is capable of reliably measuring the key parameters of the CDM, even when these values are subject to across-trial variability. Finally, we demonstrate the practical application of the method on experimental data. Specifically, an illustrative example is presented wherein the method is employed along with estimating the probability of guessing. It is hoped that the straightforward methodology presented here will, on the one hand, help narrow the divide between theoretical constructs and empirical observations on continuous response tasks and, on the other hand, inspire cognitive psychology researchers to shift their laboratory investigations towards continuous response paradigms.
对涉及连续结果的决策范式中构成决策基础的认知过程的研究引起了旨在开发既能考虑速度又能考虑准确性的动态决策理论的建模研究人员的兴趣。这些连续模型中最重要的模型之一是循环扩散模型(CDM,Smith。心理评论,123(4),425. 2016),该模型假设在圆盘内数学上描述为随机二维 Wiener 过程的噪声累积过程。尽管该模型具有相当大的优势,但由于其数学复杂性,学者们对其的利用有限。在这里,我们提出了一种简单易用的方法,用于使用简单的公式估计 CDM 参数并将模型拟合到连续尺度数据,这些公式可以轻松计算,并且不需要模型拟合或广泛编程的理论知识。尽管简单,但我们证明了上述方法的准确性可与最大似然估计方法相媲美。此外,还提出了一种稳健的方法版本,该方法保持简单,同时对污染响应具有高度抵抗力。此外,我们表明,该方法能够可靠地测量 CDM 的关键参数,即使这些值受到跨试验变异性的影响。最后,我们在实验数据上展示了该方法的实际应用。具体来说,展示了一个说明性示例,其中使用该方法同时估计猜测的概率。希望这里提出的简单方法一方面有助于缩小连续反应任务的理论结构和经验观察之间的差距,另一方面激励认知心理学研究人员将他们的实验室研究转向连续反应范式。