Department of Psychiatry, Singapore General Hospital, Singapore, Singapore; SingHealth Duke-NUS Medicine Academic Clinical Programme, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore; Health Services and Systems Research, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore; Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
Medicine Academic Clinical Programme, Singapore General Hospital, Singapore, Singapore.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 May;348:116845. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.116845. Epub 2024 Apr 4.
Higher educational attainment is strongly associated with a reduced risk of neurocognitive disorders (NCDs). However, the literature is not yet clear on (1) the minimum years of compulsory education that would sufficiently mitigate the risk of NCDs, and (2) whether educational attainment has differential effects across sexes. To bridge these gaps, this study sought to model potential non-linear relationship between years of education and NCD risk, across men and women.
The study recruited 17,671 participants from Alzheimer's Disease Centres across United States, aged≥50 years and had normal cognition at baseline. Participants were followed up almost annually, and underwent standardized assessments to diagnose various aetiologies of NCDs. Cox proportional hazard regression was conducted to examine the relationship between years of education and NCD risk, stratified by sexes. Years of education were modelled using restricted cubic spline.
Lesser years of education were associated with higher NCD risk in both sexes (specifically, when <12 years of education; HR 1.80-3.48), yet with key differences across sexes. In women, a linear relationship was observed whereby increasing years of education reduced NCD risk correspondingly; but in men, the relationship was non-linear whereby adding years of education beyond 12 years did not reduce NCD risk further. Men of lower educational attainment were at risk of both Alzheimer's Disease (AD; HR up to 3.45) and non-AD (HR up to 2.57), while women of lower educational attainment were only at risk of AD (HR up to 2.11).
Educational attainment alters NCD risk differently across sexes, emphasizing the relevance of sex-specific research to better understand the moderating role of sex on NCD risk. The findings also highlight the need to reconsider public policies related to equitable access to education, as well as traditional assumptions on the minimum years of compulsory education.
较高的受教育程度与神经认知障碍(NCD)的风险降低密切相关。然而,文献尚不清楚(1)足以降低 NCD 风险的最低年限义务教育,以及(2)教育程度对性别是否有不同的影响。为了弥补这些空白,本研究旨在为男性和女性建立教育年限与 NCD 风险之间的潜在非线性关系模型。
该研究在美国各地的阿尔茨海默病中心招募了 17671 名年龄≥50 岁且基线时认知正常的参与者。参与者几乎每年接受一次随访,并接受标准化评估以诊断各种 NCD 的病因。Cox 比例风险回归用于检验教育年限与 NCD 风险之间的关系,按性别分层。使用限制立方样条对受教育年限进行建模。
受教育年限较少与两性的 NCD 风险较高相关(具体而言,当<12 年时,HR1.80-3.48),但两性之间存在关键差异。在女性中,观察到线性关系,即增加受教育年限相应降低 NCD 风险;但在男性中,关系是非线性的,即超过 12 年的受教育年限的增加不会进一步降低 NCD 风险。受教育程度较低的男性患阿尔茨海默病(AD;HR 高达 3.45)和非 AD(HR 高达 2.57)的风险较高,而受教育程度较低的女性仅患 AD(HR 高达 2.11)的风险较高。
教育程度对两性的 NCD 风险的影响不同,强调了性别特异性研究对于更好地理解性别对 NCD 风险的调节作用的相关性。研究结果还强调了需要重新考虑与公平获得教育相关的公共政策,以及对义务教育最低年限的传统假设。