Liew Tau Ming
Department of Psychiatry, Singapore General Hospital, Outram Road, Singapore, 169608, Singapore.
SingHealth Duke-NUS Medicine Academic Clinical Programme, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore.
Alzheimers Res Ther. 2025 Jul 21;17(1):167. doi: 10.1186/s13195-025-01810-x.
Test items in MoCA (Montreal Cognitive Assessment) can be used to generate 5 domain scores (i.e. Memory, Language, Attention, Executive and Visuospatial) which have been shown to approximate well-established neuropsychological tests. As neuropsychological tests are known to be affected by age, sex, education, and language of administration, this study derived a regression-based Z-score calculator for MoCA Domain Scores (MDS) that adjusts individual performance for these key confounders; with the intention of improving the clinical utility of MDS as a proxy for conventional neuropsychological tests.
Participants ≥ 50 years were recruited from Alzheimer's Disease Centers across USA (n = 25,330), and completed MoCA and conventional neuropsychological tests. A subset with normal cognition and global Clinical Dementia Rating of 0 (n = 11,371) was used to derive the Z-score calculator for MDS; while the full sample (n = 25,330) verified the performance of MDS Z-scores in detecting domain-specific impairments (as defined by conventional neuropsychological tests), using areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC).
MDS varied significantly by age, sex, education, and language of administration even among participants with normal cognition. Based on age-, sex-, education-, and language-adjusted Z-scores, the respective AUCs were 91.2% for MoCA-Memory (95%CI 90.7-91.6), 83.6% for MoCA-Language (95%CI 83.0-84.3), 88.7% for MoCA-Attention (95%CI 88.0-89.4), 85.5% for MoCA-Executive (95%CI 84.8-86.1), and 81.0% for MoCA-Visuospatial (95%CI 80.2-81.8). At the commonly-used cut-off of Z-scores ≤ -1.50, all the MDS had specificities of ≥ 80%.
MDS Z-scores can be easily computed using the newly-developed Excel-based calculator, and provide a viable alternative when conventional neuropsychological tests are needed but cannot be feasibly administered, such as in non-specialty clinics with large volume of patients at high-risk of cognitive impairment (e.g. primary-care, geriatric, and stroke-prevention clinics), and, with further validation and calibration, plausibly also in other resource-limited healthcare settings (e.g. in lower- and middle-income countries). They can complement neuropsychological tests as part of the systematic evaluation of cognitive impairment, and help reserve neuropsychological tests for patients most likely to benefit from further evaluation.
蒙特利尔认知评估量表(MoCA)中的测试项目可用于生成5个领域得分(即记忆、语言、注意力、执行功能和视觉空间能力),这些得分已被证明与成熟的神经心理学测试结果高度相似。由于已知神经心理学测试会受到年龄、性别、教育程度和测试语言的影响,本研究基于回归分析得出了一个MoCA领域得分(MDS)的Z分数计算器,该计算器可针对这些关键混杂因素对个体表现进行调整;旨在提高MDS作为传统神经心理学测试替代指标的临床实用性。
从美国各地的阿尔茨海默病中心招募年龄≥50岁的参与者(n = 25330),他们完成了MoCA和传统神经心理学测试。使用认知正常且总体临床痴呆评定量表评分为0的一个子集(n = 11371)来推导MDS的Z分数计算器;而完整样本(n = 25330)则使用受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC)来验证MDS Z分数在检测特定领域损伤(如传统神经心理学测试所定义)方面的表现。
即使在认知正常的参与者中,MDS也因年龄、性别、教育程度和测试语言而有显著差异。基于年龄、性别、教育程度和语言调整后的Z分数,MoCA-记忆领域的AUC分别为91.2%(95%CI 90.7 - 91.6),MoCA-语言领域为83.6%(95%CI 83.0 - 84.3),MoCA-注意力领域为88.7%(95%CI 88.0 - 89.4),MoCA-执行功能领域为85.5%(95%CI 84.8 - 86.1),MoCA-视觉空间能力领域为81.0%(95%CI 80.2 - 81.8)。在常用的Z分数≤ -1.50的临界值时,所有MDS的特异性均≥80%。
使用新开发的基于Excel的计算器可以轻松计算MDS Z分数,当需要进行传统神经心理学测试但无法切实实施时,例如在有大量认知障碍高危患者的非专科诊所(如初级保健、老年病和中风预防诊所),MDS Z分数提供了一种可行的替代方法;并且经过进一步验证和校准后,在其他资源有限的医疗环境(如中低收入国家)可能也适用。它们可以作为认知障碍系统评估的一部分,补充神经心理学测试,并有助于将神经心理学测试保留给最有可能从进一步评估中受益的患者。