Division of Medical Education, School of Medical Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Educ Prim Care. 2024 Sep;35(5):166-173. doi: 10.1080/14739879.2024.2336211. Epub 2024 Apr 14.
Near-peer teaching offers mutual benefits for clinical trainees and the students they teach. However, General Practice Speciality Trainees (GPSTs) are typically less involved in community-based teaching than their hospital-based peers and often do so without formal pedagogical training. This study details the immediate and longer-term evaluation of a teaching skills course delivered to final year GPSTs. It addresses a gap within existing near-peer literature which, although extensive, is predominantly hospital-based and limited to short-term outcomes.
The course was designed and delivered to all local final year GPST schemes. Pre- and post-course questionnaires scoring confidence, comfort, and understanding of teaching roles were analysed across two years' delivery. Furthermore, individual interviews of participants 4-6 months after attendance were thematically analysed to explore how GPSTs translated course content into practice.
GPSTs reported a decline in their teaching activities as they embarked on their final year of GP teaching. Immediate post-course teaching-related confidence and knowledge scores increased. However, follow-up interviews revealed that GPSTs' initial enthusiasm was short-lived and outweighed by competing demands within an intensive short-duration training scheme. They expressed concerns about their own learner status as they themselves developed competency in a vast and varied speciality, and cited a lack of support from their trainers.
Teaching skill courses alone are insufficient to address the ongoing challenges of enhancing the teaching role of GPSTs. Further work is now needed to explore multi-level interventions to promote the role of GPSTs as near-peer teachers to harness the mutual benefits to all involved.
同伴教学对临床受训者和他们所教的学生都有好处。然而,全科医学专科培训生(GPSTs)通常比他们在医院的同龄人参与更少的社区教学,而且通常没有接受过正式的教学培训。本研究详细介绍了向最后一年的 GPST 提供教学技能课程的即时和长期评估。它解决了现有同伴教学文献中的一个空白,尽管该文献广泛,但主要是基于医院的,并且仅限于短期结果。
该课程是为所有当地的最后一年 GPST 计划设计和提供的。在两年的交付过程中,对课前和课后的问卷进行了分析,这些问卷对信心、舒适度和对教学角色的理解进行了评分。此外,对参加课程 4-6 个月后的参与者进行了个人访谈,并对访谈内容进行了主题分析,以探讨 GPSTs 如何将课程内容转化为实践。
GPSTs 报告说,随着他们进入全科医学教学的最后一年,他们的教学活动有所减少。课程结束后立即增加了与教学相关的信心和知识评分。然而,后续访谈显示,GPSTs 的最初热情是短暂的,并且被一个密集的短期培训计划中的竞争需求所抵消。他们对自己作为学习者的地位表示担忧,因为他们自己在一个广泛而多样的专业中发展了能力,并指出缺乏来自培训师的支持。
仅仅教授教学技能课程不足以解决增强 GPST 教学角色的持续挑战。现在需要进一步努力探索多层次的干预措施,以促进 GPST 作为同伴教师的角色,从而使所有相关人员都能受益。