Jeon Soha, Lee Eun-Young, Nam Sang-Jip, Lim Kyung-Min
College of Pharmacy, Ewha Womans University, Seoul, 03760, Republic of Korea.
Department of Chemistry and Nanoscience, Ewha Womans University, Seoul, 03760, Republic of Korea.
Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2024 May;149:105620. doi: 10.1016/j.yrtph.2024.105620. Epub 2024 Apr 12.
Botanical extracts, widely used in cosmetics, pose a challenge to safety assessment due to their complex compositions. The threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) approach, offering a safe exposure level for cosmetic ingredients, proves to be a promising solution for ensuring the safety of cosmetic ingredients with low exposure level. We assessed the safety of Paeonia lactiflora root extract (PLR), commonly used in skin conditioning products, with the TTC. We identified 50 constituents of PLR extract from the USDA database and literature exploration. Concentration of each constituent of PLR extract was determined with the information from USDA references, literature, and experimental analysis. The genotoxicity of PLR and its constituents was assessed in vitro and in silico respectively. Cramer class of the constituents of the PLR extract was determined with Toxtree 3.1 extended decision tree using ChemTunes®. Systemic exposure of each constituent from leave-on type cosmetic products containing PLR at a 1% concentration was estimated and compared with respective TTC threshold. Two constituents exceeding TTC threshold were further analyzed for dermal absorption using in silico tools, which confirmed the safety of PLR extract in cosmetics. Collectively, we demonstrated that the TTC is a useful tool for assessing botanical extract safety in cosmetics.
植物提取物广泛应用于化妆品中,因其成分复杂,给安全性评估带来了挑战。毒理学关注阈值(TTC)方法为化妆品成分提供了一个安全暴露水平,被证明是确保低暴露水平化妆品成分安全性的一个有前景的解决方案。我们用TTC评估了常用于皮肤调理产品中的芍药根提取物(PLR)的安全性。我们通过美国农业部数据库和文献检索确定了PLR提取物的50种成分。利用美国农业部参考文献、文献和实验分析中的信息确定了PLR提取物各成分的浓度。分别在体外和计算机模拟中评估了PLR及其成分的遗传毒性。使用ChemTunes®的Toxtree 3.1扩展决策树确定了PLR提取物成分的克莱默分类。估计了含有1%浓度PLR的免洗型化妆品中各成分的全身暴露量,并与各自的TTC阈值进行了比较。使用计算机模拟工具对两种超过TTC阈值的成分进行了皮肤吸收的进一步分析,这证实了PLR提取物在化妆品中的安全性。总体而言,我们证明了TTC是评估化妆品中植物提取物安全性的一个有用工具。