1Interdisciplinary Consortium on Ambulatory Motion Performance (iCAMP), Division of Vascular Surgery and Endovascular Therapy, Michael E. DeBakey Department of Surgery, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas; and.
2Division of Neurosurgery, Department of Surgery, University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson, Arizona.
J Neurosurg Spine. 2024 Apr 19;41(1):135-145. doi: 10.3171/2024.1.SPINE231001. Print 2024 Jul 1.
Physical stress associated with the static posture of neurosurgeons over prolonged periods can result in fatigue and musculoskeletal disorders. Objective assessment of surgical ergonomics may contribute to postural awareness and prevent further complications. This pilot study examined the feasibility of using wearable technology as a biofeedback tool to address this gap.
Ten neurosurgeons, including 5 attendings (all faculty) and 5 trainees (1 fellow, 4 residents), were recruited and equipped with two wearable sensors attached to the back of their head and their upper back. The sensors collected the average time spent in extended (≤ -10°), neutral (> -10° and < 10°), and flexed (≥ 10°) static postures (undetected activity for more than 10 seconds) during spine and cranial procedures. Feasibility outcomes aimed for more than 70% of accurate data collection. Exploratory outcomes included the comparison of postural variability within and between participants adjusted to their demographics excluding nonrelated surgical activities, and postoperative self-assessment surveys.
Sixteen (80%) of 20 possible recordings were successfully collected and analyzed from 11 procedures (8 spine, 3 cranial). Surgeons maintained a static posture during 52.7% of the active surgical time (mean 1.58 hrs). During spine procedures, all surgeons used an exoscope while standing, leading to a significantly longer time spent in a neutral static posture (p < 0.001, partial η2 = 0.14): attendings remained longer in a neutral static posture (36.4% ± 15.3%) than in the extended (9% ± 6.3%) and flexed (5.7% ± 3.4%) static postures; trainees also remained longer in a neutral static posture (30.2% ± 13.8%) than in the extended (11.1% ± 6.3%) and flexed (11.9% ± 6.6%) static postures. During cranial procedures, surgeons intermittently transitioned between standing/exoscope use and sitting/microscope use, with trainees spending a shorter time in a neutral static posture (16.3% vs 48.5%, p < 0.001) and a longer time in a flexed static posture (18.5% vs 2.7%, p < 0.001) compared with attendings. Additionally, longer cranial procedures correlated with surgeons spending a longer time (r = 0.94) in any static posture (extended, flexed, and neutral), with taller surgeons exhibiting longer periods in flexed and extended static postures (r = 0.86). Postoperative self-assessment revealed that attendings perceived spine procedures as more difficult than trainees (p = 0.029), while trainees found cranial procedures to be of greater difficulty than spine procedures (p = 0.012). Attendings felt more stressed (p = 0.048), less calmed (p = 0.024), less relaxed (p = 0.048), and experienced greater stiffness in their upper body (p = 0.048) and more shoulder pain (p = 0.024) during cranial versus spine procedures.
Wearable technology is feasible to assess postural ergonomics and provide objective biofeedback to neurosurgeons during spine and cranial procedures. This study showed reproducibility for future comparative protocols focused on correcting posture and surgical ergonomic education.
神经外科医生长时间保持静态姿势会导致身体疲劳和肌肉骨骼疾病。客观评估手术工效学可以提高姿势意识,防止进一步出现并发症。本研究旨在探讨使用可穿戴技术作为生物反馈工具来解决这一问题的可行性。
招募了 10 名神经外科医生,包括 5 名主治医生(均为教员)和 5 名受训医生(1 名研究员,4 名住院医生),并为他们配备了两个可穿戴传感器,分别贴在他们的头部和上背部。传感器收集脊柱和颅部手术过程中处于伸展(≤-10°)、中立(>-10°且<10°)和弯曲(≥10°)静态姿势的平均时间(超过 10 秒无活动)。可行性研究的目的是实现超过 70%的准确数据收集。探索性研究的结果包括调整参与者的人口统计学数据(排除与手术无关的活动)后,比较参与者之间和参与者内部的姿势变化,并进行术后自我评估调查。
11 例手术中成功采集并分析了 20 次记录中的 16 次(80%)。手术过程中,医生的静态姿势维持时间占手术总时长的 52.7%(平均 1.58 小时)。在脊柱手术中,所有医生都站着使用内窥镜,导致他们处于中立静态姿势的时间显著延长(p<0.001,部分η2=0.14):主治医生在中立静态姿势下的停留时间(36.4%±15.3%)长于伸展(9%±6.3%)和弯曲(5.7%±3.4%)静态姿势;受训医生在中立静态姿势下的停留时间(30.2%±13.8%)也长于伸展(11.1%±6.3%)和弯曲(11.9%±6.6%)静态姿势。在颅部手术中,医生间歇性地从站立/使用内窥镜转换为坐立/使用显微镜,与主治医生相比,受训医生处于中立静态姿势的时间更短(16.3%比 48.5%,p<0.001),处于弯曲静态姿势的时间更长(18.5%比 2.7%,p<0.001)。此外,较长的颅部手术与医生处于任何静态姿势(伸展、弯曲和中立)的时间延长相关(r=0.94),而较高的医生表现出更长时间的弯曲和伸展静态姿势(r=0.86)。术后自我评估显示,主治医生认为脊柱手术比受训医生更难(p=0.029),而受训医生认为颅部手术比脊柱手术更难(p=0.012)。与脊柱手术相比,主治医生在颅部手术中感觉压力更大(p=0.048)、平静度更低(p=0.024)、放松度更低(p=0.048)、上半身僵硬度更大(p=0.048)、肩部疼痛更严重(p=0.024)。
可穿戴技术可用于评估脊柱和颅部手术中的手术工效学,并为神经外科医生提供客观的生物反馈。本研究为未来的研究提供了可重复性,这些研究旨在通过纠正姿势和手术工效学教育来改善手术效果。