Faculty of Physical Culture, Palacký University Olomouc, Olomouc, Czechia.
Cardiff School of Sport and Health Sciences, Cardiff Metropolitan University, Cardiff, UK.
J Adolesc. 2024 Aug;96(6):1368-1378. doi: 10.1002/jad.12331. Epub 2024 Apr 17.
There is a consensus that adolescents' participation in organized leisure-time activities (OLTAs) is pro-developmental and beneficial for youth mental health. While enjoyment in OLTA is commonly regarded as positive, the role of obligation in the context of adolescents' OLTA has been scarcely researched. The present study investigated how these theoretically contradictory experiences (enjoyment and/or obligation) in OLTA participation relate to adolescents' wellbeing and incidence of psychological complaints accounting for their possible co-occurrence.
A nationally representative sample of 14,128 eleven-fifteen-year-old adolescents (49.7% girls) drawn from the Czech 2021/2022 Health Behaviour in School-aged Children cross-sectional study was used. A series of multivariate regression analyses assessed how perceptions of obligation and enjoyment in OLTA related to wellbeing and occurrence of psychological complaints. A person-centered approach derived groups of respondents on the basis of their perceptions of obligation and enjoyment.
Regression analyses, controlled for sociodemographic and family environment factors, and dimensions of OLTA participation, indicated that adolescents enjoying their OLTA displayed more favourable mental wellbeing reports. In contrast, perceptions of obligation were only weakly associated with more frequent psychological complaints and not at all with wellbeing, unless adolescents also reported the lack of enjoyment.
Enjoyment in OLTA plays a pivotal role in the association between OLTA participation and mental health, whereas the role of obligation is far less pronounced. In fact, if adolescents do not enjoy their participation, but feel obliged to participate, their self-assessed mental wellbeing is comparable to their peers not participating in OLTA at all.
人们普遍认为,青少年参与有组织的闲暇时间活动(OLTAs)是有利于发展的,对青少年的心理健康有益。虽然普遍认为参与 OLTAs 是愉快的,但在青少年 OLTAs 背景下,义务的作用几乎没有得到研究。本研究调查了这些理论上相互矛盾的体验(享受和/或义务)在 OLTAs 参与中如何与青少年的幸福感和心理问题的发生相关,同时考虑了它们可能的共同发生。
本研究使用了来自捷克 2021/2022 年健康行为在学龄儿童横断面研究的具有全国代表性的 14128 名 11-15 岁青少年(49.7%为女孩)样本。一系列多元回归分析评估了 OLTAs 参与中的义务和享受感知与幸福感和心理问题发生的关系。基于对义务和享受的感知,采用一种个体中心的方法对受访者进行分组。
回归分析控制了社会人口和家庭环境因素以及 OLTAs 参与的维度,表明享受 OLTAs 的青少年表现出更有利的心理健康报告。相比之下,义务感仅与更频繁的心理问题有微弱关联,与幸福感无关,除非青少年也报告缺乏享受感。
在 OLTAs 参与与心理健康之间的关联中,享受 OLTAs 起着关键作用,而义务的作用则不那么明显。事实上,如果青少年不享受他们的参与,而是感到有义务参与,那么他们的自我评估的心理健康与根本不参与 OLTAs 的同龄人相当。