Datchanamourtty Priyanga, Rajalakshmi M, Ganapathy Kalaiselvan
Department of Community Medicine, Sri Manakula Vinayagar Medical College and Hospital, Puducherry, India.
Department of Community and Family Medicine, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Mangalagiri, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh, India.
Indian J Palliat Care. 2024 Jan-Mar;30(1):21-26. doi: 10.25259/IJPC_228_2023. Epub 2024 Feb 16.
We, the Department of Community Medicine, have been training healthcare providers for palliative care in the hospital and community setting. There were many difficulties in providing proper palliative care. The objective is to explore the various difficulties faced by Junior Residents, auxiliary nurse and midwife (ANM) and medical social workers (MSWs) during the home visits of palliative care patients and to address those difficulties in future visits.
The study was conducted in our peripheral institutions such as the Rural Health Training Centre and the Urban Health Training Centre among Junior Residents, ANMs and MSWs who had provided palliative care for the patients. Qualitative study design includes participatory research action techniques such as force field analysis, cobweb diagram, and pairwise ranking, and Systematic techniques include the Delphi technique.
Indicators for difficulties faced by Junior Residents were derived and plotted based on priorities and joined to form a cobweb diagram. Difficulties were time constraints, lack of resources such as medications and transport facilities, need for specialist care, and non-adherence to the advice. Driving force and restraining force for palliative care were derived and plotted on the force field analysis. The favourable factors in providing palliative care services of the healthcare providers are self-satisfaction with treating the patient, satisfaction due to treatment at the doorstep, understanding the patient's psychological or social factors affecting their health, skill development and counselling of the patient. The restraining factors in providing palliative care services of the healthcare providers are time constraints, lack of resources, patient not following the advice properly, improper care by caregivers and unable to fulfill certain needs of the patient. Pairwise scoring/ranking was done for MSWs by plotting the issues faced in palliative care visits in rows and columns. The difficulties were time constraints, lack of resources, lack of proper knowledge of staff and need for specialist care. The possible potential solutions derived from the Delphi technique were proper planning to reduce time constraints and intense counseling of patients on adherence to treatment.
It helped to identify the difficulties faced by healthcare providers and to plan for solutions in future palliative home care visits.
我们社区医学系一直在医院和社区环境中培训姑息治疗的医疗服务提供者。提供适当的姑息治疗存在许多困难。目的是探讨初级住院医师、辅助护士和助产士(ANM)以及医务社会工作者(MSW)在姑息治疗患者家访期间面临的各种困难,并在未来的家访中解决这些困难。
该研究在我们的周边机构进行,如农村卫生培训中心和城市卫生培训中心,研究对象为曾为患者提供姑息治疗的初级住院医师、ANM和MSW。定性研究设计包括参与式研究行动技术,如力场分析、蛛网图和成对排序,系统技术包括德尔菲技术。
根据优先级得出并绘制了初级住院医师面临困难的指标,并将其连接形成一个蛛网图。困难包括时间限制、缺乏药物和交通设施等资源、需要专科护理以及不遵守建议。在力场分析中得出并绘制了姑息治疗的驱动力和约束力。医疗服务提供者提供姑息治疗服务的有利因素包括对治疗患者的自我满足感、因上门治疗而产生的满足感、理解影响患者健康的心理或社会因素、技能发展以及对患者的咨询。医疗服务提供者提供姑息治疗服务的制约因素包括时间限制、资源缺乏、患者未正确遵循建议、护理人员护理不当以及无法满足患者的某些需求。通过将姑息治疗访视中面临的问题绘制在行和列中,对MSW进行了成对评分/排序。困难包括时间限制、资源缺乏、工作人员缺乏适当知识以及需要专科护理。从德尔菲技术得出的可能的潜在解决方案是进行适当规划以减少时间限制,并对患者进行强化咨询以使其坚持治疗。
这有助于识别医疗服务提供者面临的困难,并为未来的姑息家庭护理访视规划解决方案。