Boakye Priscilla N, Prendergast Nadia, Bailey Annette, Sharon McCleod, Bandari Bahareh, Odutayo Awura-Ama, Anane Brown Eugenia
Toronto Metropolitan University, Toronto, ON, Canada.
University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Can J Nurs Res. 2025 Mar;57(1):59-68. doi: 10.1177/08445621241247865. Epub 2024 Apr 22.
BackgroundStereotype about Black people contribute to nurses and healthcare providers gaslighting and dismissing of their health concerns. Despite the popularity of the term medical gaslighting in mainstream literature, few studies have explored the experiences of Black women during pregnancy and childbirth.PurposeThis paper aims to provide an in-depth insight into Black women's experiences of anti-Black medical gaslighting when accessing care during pregnancy and childbirth.MethodsUtilizing qualitative methods, we conducted 24 semi-structured interviews with Black women in the Greater Toronto Area. We used thematic analysis to ground the data analysis and to generate insight into Black women's experiences.ResultsThree overarching themes: 1) Not Being Understood: Privileging of Medical Knowledge Contributing to the Downplaying of Health Concerns, 2) Not Being Believed: Stereotypes Contributing to Dismissive Healthcare Encounters and 3) Listen to Us: Turning off the Cycle of Medical Gaslighting. These themes highlight ways anti-Black medical gaslighting manifests in Black women's healthcare encounters to create differential access to treatment and care.ConclusionsAnti-Black medical gaslighting contributes to differential access to treatment and care. Improving equitable access to treatment and care must involve addressing structural and epistemic biases in healthcare and fostering a culture of listening to humanize the experience of illness.
背景
对黑人的刻板印象导致护士和医疗服务提供者对黑人的健康问题进行煤气灯效应(指通过歪曲、否定等手段让受害者怀疑自己的认知)并不予理会。尽管“医疗煤气灯效应”一词在主流文献中很流行,但很少有研究探讨黑人女性在怀孕和分娩期间的经历。
目的
本文旨在深入了解黑人女性在怀孕和分娩期间接受护理时遭遇反黑人医疗煤气灯效应的经历。
方法
我们采用定性方法,对大多伦多地区的黑人女性进行了24次半结构化访谈。我们使用主题分析来进行数据分析,并深入了解黑人女性的经历。
结果
1)不被理解:医学知识的特权化导致对健康问题的轻视,2)不被相信:刻板印象导致轻视性的医疗遭遇,3)倾听我们:打破医疗煤气灯效应的循环。这些主题突出了反黑人医疗煤气灯效应在黑人女性医疗遭遇中表现出来的方式,从而造成了获得治疗和护理的差异。
结论
反黑人医疗煤气灯效应导致获得治疗和护理的差异。改善公平获得治疗和护理的机会必须包括解决医疗保健中的结构性和认知偏见,并营造一种倾听的文化,以使疾病体验人性化。