Department of Urology, St Vincent's University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Department of Radiology, St James Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
World J Urol. 2024 Apr 22;42(1):249. doi: 10.1007/s00345-024-04967-6.
Prostate biopsy is central to the accurate histological diagnosis of prostate cancer. In current practice, the biopsy procedure can be performed using a transrectal or transperineal route with different technologies available for targeting of lesions within the prostate. Historically, the biopsy procedure was performed solely by urologists, but with the advent of image-guided techniques, the involvement of radiologists in prostate biopsy has become more common. Herein, we discuss the pros, cons and future considerations regarding their ongoing role.
A narrative review regarding the current evidence was completed. PubMed and Cochrane central register of controlled trials were search until January 2024. All study types were of consideration if published after 2000 and an English language translation was available.
There are no published studies that directly compare outcomes of prostate biopsy when performed by a urologist or radiologist. In all published studies regarding the learning curve for prostate biopsy, the procedure was performed by urologists. These studies suggest that the learning curve for prostate biopsy is between 10 and 50 cases to reach proficiency in terms of prostate cancer detection and complications. It is recognised that many urologists are poorly able to accurately interpret multi parametric (mp)-MRI of the prostate. Collaboration between the specialities is of importance with urology offering the advantage of being involved in prior and future care of the patient while radiology has the advantage of being able to expertly interpret preprocedure MRI.
There is no evidence to suggest that prostate biopsy should be solely performed by a specific specialty. The most important factor remains knowledge of the relevant anatomy and sufficient volume of cases to develop and maintain skills.
前列腺活检是准确诊断前列腺癌的关键。在当前的实践中,活检程序可以通过经直肠或经会阴途径进行,并且可以使用不同的技术来靶向前列腺内的病变。历史上,活检程序仅由泌尿科医生进行,但随着影像引导技术的出现,放射科医生在前列腺活检中的参与变得更加普遍。在此,我们讨论了他们持续作用的优缺点和未来考虑因素。
完成了一篇关于当前证据的叙述性综述。检索了 PubMed 和 Cochrane 对照试验中心注册库,直到 2024 年 1 月。如果发表于 2000 年后且有英文翻译,所有研究类型都在考虑范围内。
没有发表的研究直接比较泌尿科医生或放射科医生进行前列腺活检的结果。在所有关于前列腺活检学习曲线的已发表研究中,该程序均由泌尿科医生进行。这些研究表明,前列腺活检的学习曲线在 10 到 50 例之间,以达到在前列腺癌检测和并发症方面的熟练程度。人们认识到,许多泌尿科医生无法准确解读多参数(mp)-MRI 前列腺。专业之间的协作很重要,泌尿科医生在患者的前期和后续护理中具有优势,而放射科医生则具有熟练解读术前 MRI 的优势。
没有证据表明前列腺活检应由特定专业单独进行。最重要的因素仍然是对相关解剖结构的了解以及足够数量的病例来发展和保持技能。