Grineski Sara E, Griego Angel, Mullen Casey, Collins Timothy W, Nadybal Shawna, Mangadu Aparna
Department of Sociology, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
Department of Geography, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
Environ Justice. 2024 Feb;17(1):15-30. doi: 10.1089/env.2021.0113. Epub 2022 Dec 23.
Tree canopy cover has mental and physical health benefits for children, yet distributional environmental injustices in tree canopy cover near schools are rarely investigated. Some evidence suggests that tree canopy coverage positively influences aggregated school-level children's academic proficiency metrics. There is a lack of research if canopy cover moderates the negative effect of particulate matter on academic proficiency.
We linked data on schools from the National Center for Education Statistics, Utah's Student Assessment of Growth and Excellence, the National Land Cover Database, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. We used generalized estimating equations, which account for non-normally distributed data and clustering, to analyze data from the 2015 to 2016 school year.
Greater school social disadvantage (higher percentages of students qualifying for free/reduced price meals and higher percentages of racial/ethnic minority students) was significantly associated with reductions in tree canopy cover within 1000 m and 500 m of the school. Greater tree canopy coverage at 1000 m and 500 m was significantly associated with a lower percentage of students testing below proficient on year-end math and language arts exams. Additional days of peak fine particulate matter were associated with higher percentages of students testing below proficient in math.
Socially disadvantaged primary schools in Utah were surrounded by less canopy cover. There was a protective effect of tree canopy cover on academic proficiency in math and language arts.
Findings suggest targeting carefully designed tree planting efforts at socially disadvantaged schools and testing interventions involving tree planting and changes in academic proficiency.
树冠覆盖对儿童的身心健康有益,但学校附近树冠覆盖的分布性环境不公现象却很少被研究。一些证据表明,树冠覆盖率对学校层面儿童学业成绩的综合指标有积极影响。关于树冠覆盖是否能减轻颗粒物对学业成绩的负面影响,目前还缺乏相关研究。
我们将来自美国国家教育统计中心、犹他州学生成长与卓越评估、美国国家土地覆盖数据库和美国环境保护局的学校数据进行了关联。我们使用了广义估计方程来分析2015至2016学年的数据,该方程考虑了非正态分布的数据和聚类情况。
学校社会劣势程度越高(符合免费/减价餐条件的学生比例越高,以及种族/族裔少数学生比例越高),学校周围1000米和500米范围内的树冠覆盖减少就越显著。学校周围1000米和500米处树冠覆盖率越高,年终数学和语言艺术考试中成绩未达熟练水平的学生比例就越低。额外的细颗粒物峰值天数与数学成绩未达熟练水平的学生比例较高有关。
犹他州社会弱势小学周围的树冠覆盖较少。树冠覆盖对数学和语言艺术的学业成绩有保护作用。
研究结果表明,应针对社会弱势学校开展精心设计的植树活动,并测试涉及植树和学业成绩变化的干预措施。