AlAbdullah Ghufran, Al Ahmed Fatemah, Alatiyyah Zahra J, Alibraheem Ghadeer, Almuqahwi Abdullah
College of Medicine, King Faisal University, Al-Ahsa, SAU.
Family Medicine, King Faisal University, Al-Ahsa, SAU.
Cureus. 2024 Mar 31;16(3):e57344. doi: 10.7759/cureus.57344. eCollection 2024 Mar.
Introduction Being the first in-line care providers, primary healthcare (PHC) physicians may encounter all forms of medical emergencies, ranging from minor complaints to major life-threatening events; therefore, this study aims to assess the PHC physicians' knowledge and attitude related to the diagnosis and management of emergency cases as well as their preferences for emergency medicine training courses and their preferred methods of training. Methods A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted among physicians working at PHC in Al-Ahsa, Saudi Arabia, between November and December 2023, excluding those who do not work at PHC. The minimum required sample size was 192. A self-administered online questionnaire was developed using Google Forms and distributed conveniently through social media platforms. It consists of 22 items categorized into four sections: The first section focused on demographic information; the second section assessed knowledge related to the diagnosis and management of emergency cases commonly encountered in PHC, along with actual management experiences; the third section gauged physicians' attitudes, and the fourth section explored participants' preferences for emergency medicine courses and their preferred methods of training in this field. The Kruskal-Wallis rank sum and Wilcoxon rank sum tests were employed to identify predictors of knowledge and attitude. Results The study involved 193 participants, with 96 (50%) females and a median age of 30 years. The participants included 43 (22%) consultants, 69 (36%) family residents, 30 (16%) general practitioners, and 50 (26%) specialists. Participants reported a median of 4.0 years of experience in PHC in Saudi Arabia. The majority, 69 (36%), reported working in the hospital emergency department, with a reported median duration of three months. Roughly 84% of PHC physicians had a positive attitude toward emergency cases diagnosis and management, while 92% showed fair diagnostic knowledge of emergency cases, and 73% showed fair management knowledge. Higher knowledge in the diagnosis and management of PHC was linked to increasing age, being consultants, being employed in the emergency department, and having higher years of experience in PHC (p < 0.05). A positive attitude toward PHC was found to be associated with working as a consultant and being employed in the emergency department (p < 0.05). Approximately 133 (68.9%) expressed a preference for a course in wound care trauma, followed by central nervous system emergencies (n = 124, 64.2%), coronary artery disease emergencies (n = 116, 60.1%), and obstetrics/gynecologic emergencies (n = 114, 59.1%) with 160 (82.9%) favored training through practice in PHC under supervision of qualified staff. Conclusion While many PHC centers are well equipped and prepared for early stabilization and management of emergency cases, PHC physicians showed low competency in dealing with emergency cases. This indicates a great need for enhancing physician's knowledge and skills regarding emergency situations. Nevertheless, courses like basic life support (BLS) and advanced trauma life support (ATLS) should be the bare minimum requirements for PHC physicians. Mote advance training and lectures should be organized to enhance PHC physician competencies to deal with different emergencies.
引言 作为一线医疗服务的提供者,初级医疗保健(PHC)医生可能会遇到各种形式的医疗紧急情况,从小病到危及生命的重大事件;因此,本研究旨在评估PHC医生在急诊病例诊断和管理方面的知识与态度,以及他们对急诊医学培训课程的偏好和首选培训方法。
方法 2023年11月至12月期间,在沙特阿拉伯艾哈萨的PHC工作的医生中开展了一项描述性横断面研究,不包括那些不在PHC工作的医生。所需的最小样本量为192。使用谷歌表单开发了一份自填式在线问卷,并通过社交媒体平台方便地进行分发。问卷由22个项目组成,分为四个部分:第一部分关注人口统计学信息;第二部分评估与PHC中常见急诊病例诊断和管理相关的知识以及实际管理经验;第三部分衡量医生的态度,第四部分探索参与者对急诊医学课程的偏好以及他们在该领域的首选培训方法。采用Kruskal-Wallis秩和检验与Wilcoxon秩和检验来确定知识和态度的预测因素。
结果 该研究涉及193名参与者,其中96名(50%)为女性,中位年龄为30岁。参与者包括43名(22%)顾问医生、69名(36%)家庭住院医生、30名(16%)全科医生和50名(26%)专科医生。参与者报告在沙特阿拉伯的PHC工作的中位年限为4.0年。大多数人,即69名(36%),报告曾在医院急诊科工作,报告的中位时长为三个月。约84%的PHC医生对急诊病例的诊断和管理持积极态度,而92%的医生对急诊病例有较好的诊断知识,73%的医生有较好的管理知识。PHC诊断和管理方面的知识水平较高与年龄增长、担任顾问医生、在急诊科工作以及在PHC工作年限较长有关(p < 0.05)。发现对PHC持积极态度与担任顾问医生以及在急诊科工作有关(p < 0.05)。约133名(68.9%)表示更喜欢伤口护理创伤课程,其次是中枢神经系统急诊(n = 124,64.2%)、冠状动脉疾病急诊(n = 116,60.1%)和妇产科急诊(n = 114,59.1%),160名(82.9%)倾向于在合格人员监督下在PHC通过实践进行培训。
结论 虽然许多PHC中心在急诊病例的早期稳定和管理方面设备齐全且准备充分,但PHC医生在处理急诊病例方面能力较低。这表明迫切需要提高医生在紧急情况下的知识和技能。然而,基础生命支持(BLS)和高级创伤生命支持(ATLS)等课程应该是PHC医生的最低要求。应组织更多高级培训和讲座,以提高PHC医生应对不同紧急情况的能力。