Umer Mohammad, Naveed Aiman, Maryam Qanita, Malik Arif Rasheed, Bashir Naghmana, Kandel Kamal
King Edward Medical University (KEMU).
Fatima Jinnah Medical University, Lahore, Pakistan.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2024 Mar 18;86(5):2606-2611. doi: 10.1097/MS9.0000000000001957. eCollection 2024 May.
The purpose of this study is to find out the level of awareness and acceptance of artificial intelligence (AI) in Pakistan's medical community so as to comment on its future in our healthcare system.
A survey consisting of 15 close-ended questions was conducted. The questions inquired about awareness about AI and discovered the opinions of healthcare professionals regarding its benefits and expected problems. The data were analyzed using SPSS version 26, and descriptive statistics for percentage and frequency were computed. χ test was used to analyze the subgroups (Significant value <0.05).
A total of 351 participants were included in this study. General familiarity with AI was low. Only 75 (21.3%) participants answered that they had good familiarity with AI, and only 56 (16%) of them had good familiarity with the role of AI in medicine. One hundred sixty-eight (47.9%) participants disagreed that AI would out-compete the physician in the important traits of professionalism. Only 71 (20.2%) participants believed AI to be diagnostically superior to the physician. Two hundred fourteen (61.0%) were worried about completely trusting AI in its decisions, and 204(58.1%) believed that AI systems lacking human traits would not be able to mirror the doctor-patient relationship. Two hundred sixty-one (74.4%) participants believed that AI would be useful in Administrative tasks. A majority, 162 (46.2%), do not believe that AI would replace them. Finally, a huge majority of participants [225 (64.1%)] demanded the integration of AI in Pakistan's healthcare system.
This study suggests that a majority of healthcare professionals in Pakistan do not believe that they are sufficiently aware of the role of AI in healthcare. This was corroborated by their answers to various questions regarding the capabilities of AI. This study indicates the need for a more comprehensive ascertainment of healthcare professionals' perceptions regarding the role of Artificial Intelligence in medicine and bridging the gap between doctors and technology to further promote a patient-centred approach to medicine.
本研究旨在了解巴基斯坦医学界对人工智能(AI)的认知和接受程度,以便对其在我国医疗体系中的未来发展进行评价。
开展了一项包含15个封闭式问题的调查。问题涉及对AI的认知,并了解医疗保健专业人员对其益处和预期问题的看法。使用SPSS 26版软件对数据进行分析,计算百分比和频率的描述性统计量。采用χ检验分析亚组(显著性值<0.05)。
本研究共纳入351名参与者。对AI的总体熟悉程度较低。只有75名(21.3%)参与者回答称他们对AI非常熟悉,其中只有56名(16%)对AI在医学中的作用非常熟悉。168名(47.9%)参与者不同意AI在专业性的重要特征方面会超过医生。只有71名(20.2%)参与者认为AI在诊断方面优于医生。214名(61.0%)参与者担心完全信任AI的决策,204名(58.1%)认为缺乏人性特征的AI系统无法反映医患关系。261名(74.4%)参与者认为AI在行政任务中会有用。大多数人,即162名(46.2%),不相信AI会取代他们。最后,绝大多数参与者[225名(64.1%)]要求在巴基斯坦医疗体系中整合AI。
本研究表明巴基斯坦的大多数医疗保健专业人员认为他们对AI在医疗保健中的作用了解不足。他们对有关AI能力的各种问题的回答证实了这一点。本研究表明需要更全面地了解医疗保健专业人员对人工智能在医学中作用的看法,并弥合医生与技术之间的差距,以进一步推动以患者为中心的医疗方法。