School of Health Sciences, Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia.
School of Health Sciences, Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia; Translational Health Research Institute (THRI), Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia.
Prev Med. 2024 Jun;183:107979. doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2024.107979. Epub 2024 Apr 30.
Limited evidence shows culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) children and adolescents are less active, compared to the general population. It is unclear, how physical activity interventions have been adapted for CALD children and adolescents to enhance engagement. This study aimed to review culturally adapted physical activity interventions targeting CALD children and adolescents.
All studies recruited children and adolescents (i.e., aged ≥5 to <18 years old) from CALD backgrounds, targeted physical activity, and included cultural adaptations. Cultural adaptations were defined as surface structures (i.e., observable characteristics of a targeted population) or deep structures (i.e., rooted in core ethnic values derived from individual cultures.
Twenty studies were included. Ten studies used a combination of surface and deep structure adaptations. Of these 10 studies, 3 found a significant between-group difference in physical activity favouring the intervention group. Among studies (n = 6) that used surface structure adaptations (e.g., language adjustments to information sheets, consent forms, and resources), 1 found a significant intervention effect on physical activity. With studies (n = 4) that used deep structure adaptations (e.g., incorporating traditional songs and dances relevant to cultural groups), 1 study found a significant intervention effect on physical activity.
A small number of studies found significant changes to increase physical activity levels. We found there is a lack of consistent evidence indicating that incorporating surface and/or deep structure adaptations result in significant changes in physical activity. Future research should focus on establishing higher quality methodology when developing culturally adapted interventions for CALD populations.
有限的证据表明,与一般人群相比,文化和语言多样化(CALD)的儿童和青少年的活动量较少。目前尚不清楚,针对 CALD 儿童和青少年的身体活动干预措施如何进行调整以提高参与度。本研究旨在回顾针对 CALD 儿童和青少年的文化适应性身体活动干预措施。
所有研究均招募了来自 CALD 背景的儿童和青少年(即年龄≥5 岁至<18 岁),以身体活动为目标,并包括文化适应。文化适应被定义为表面结构(即目标人群的可观察特征)或深层结构(即源自个体文化的核心族裔价值观)。
共纳入 20 项研究。其中 10 项研究采用了表面结构和深层结构相结合的调整方法。在这 10 项研究中,有 3 项研究发现干预组在身体活动方面存在显著的组间差异。在采用表面结构调整(例如,对信息表、同意书和资源进行语言调整)的 6 项研究中(n=6),有 1 项研究发现身体活动有显著的干预效果。在采用深层结构调整(例如,融入与文化群体相关的传统歌曲和舞蹈)的 4 项研究中(n=4),有 1 项研究发现身体活动有显著的干预效果。
少数研究发现了显著的变化,可提高身体活动水平。我们发现,没有一致的证据表明,纳入表面和/或深层结构调整会导致身体活动的显著变化。未来的研究应专注于在为 CALD 人群制定文化适应性干预措施时,建立更高质量的方法。